the idea is right, problem is that if the image is noisy you need to do a lot of filtering to get rid of artifacts (which is not good).
some things i would try:
- average several frames of the clean plate to reduce noise
- make a clean hard matte and a noisy soft matte. expand the hard matte by a few pixels and do an inside with the soft matte , shrink the hard matte a few pixels and max it with the result. this should give you a solid matte with not too harsh edges.
- try a median filter to reduce the noise.
others will probably have better ideas here ![]()
but it's a start.
++ c.