20" LCD, probably a Dell

Hi folks, i was wondering if anybody has any experience with the aforementioned TFT. I plan to use it for Maya stuff, first person shooter gaming, watching DVD’s and stuff. It will be my main screen and i run at 1600x1200.

At this point have all of the older problems associated with going TFT versus a good CRT been taken care of? I know some TFT makers claim that they have better contrast, color, sharpness, etc than a good CRT now. I was just wondering what kind of experiences folks were having with them.

The Dell is about a grand and not a bad deal in my opionion. I can then get this huge 21" CRT off my desk and finally have some room on my desk again for whatever. Also TFT are much better and easier on the eyes from what i have read.

Comments as always are appreciated.

thx,

john

I’ve been looking into getting a TFT display myself recently, and have been searching the net for reviews on various models… btw, Dell flat panel displays are re-badged Samsung’s which seem to be one of the best at present.
The response rate is still a major problem on all but one, the new Hitachi CML174SXW but unfortunately it only comes as a 17"… check out Tom’s Hardware for a review.
Everything I’ve read so far points to very bad gaming, DVD and TV performance on the majority of FPD’s, so I believe it’s not the best time to buy right now, but wait until the response times come down to below 10ms, especially if you want to play games.

Cheers

Hi John,
Im coming from a traditional graphic design background on this one, (alltough I’ve been employed as a 3D animator in the past, I needed some Job security in days like these… so im back on the old print side of things cause i can actually earn a living out of it without sacrificing my social life)

Ive just been testing a few TFT displays at my current employer. My boss is constantly going nuts over the new imac and was trying to suggest getting some for the in house artists we have, ive spent all my efforts telling him to go with PC’s with good quality CRT’s for a number of reasons:
As far as I know no TFT is capeable of displaying the colour range needed for highend print/screen/motion design, They dont have much control over contrast and brightness and as such are a real pain to calibrate and colour profile properly. The printers I use even refuse to supply colour proofs if the material was created on a TFT monitor. (!!!)
Oh yeah one other small point, Macs are too slow too expensive, and they’ve still only got one mouse button!!! Im sure that comment will ruffle a few feathers amongst the Graphic design and DTP community but im a designer too and wouldn’t touch a mac now with a barge pole!
All in all i’d say get a TFT if you really want to save on desk space but, allways, allways have a properly callibrated CRT on which you can check colour ranges and values, im just gonna get a couple of 19" mitsubishi diamond pros for my next set of monitors, they are incredibly good value for producing work where consistent colour reproduction is a must and i can get some in black to match my new case!

Hope this helps,

Sam Sharpe

Thanks for the comments guys. I think i will hold off on that new TFT purchase then.

Macs should be much better in a few months once the IBM PowerPC 970’s ship in new PowerMacs. Until that time Motorola SUCKS.

I wonder if there are any “slimer” CRTs out there 21 or 22" that won’t take up a ton of space on me. Anyone know?