4 Heads - Pick One

Ok, I just noticed something weird. If I move an image to the left or right edge of the screen it gets stretched wider. I tested this on a shadowmask and aperture grille monitor and the same thing happens. This means if I post my pics of my head onto the net and if you have your browser screen maximized, then the image appears in the top left hand edge/corner and this in turn makes the image appear wider than it would be if it were in the center of the screen. All these problems are really begining to annoy me, is anyone else getting the same effect with their monitor?

Anyways, I have 4 images here and I was wondering if I could get some opinions on which one looks best.

http://members.home.net/lancelet/4heads.jpghttp://members.home.net/lancelet/4heads.jpg

Picture 1 is the original
Picture 2 is the original with eyes closer
Picture 3 is the original with eyes closer and head shorter
Picture 3 is the original with head shorter

Thanks

-Lancelet

I think picture 3 looks best, but none look “wrong”.

Hmm… I kinda like that one too. Just goes to show how little differences can make a difference.

All the heads are about 4.75 eyelengths accross. I think Head 3 has more of a balance of spacing between the eyes. It is .75 of an eyelength from the edge to the edge of the face.

Thanks Kenneth

-Lancelet

I’ll put in a vote for #2 lance, though all of them do look good. Perhaps a change of the hair style on one and you have sisters?

Any of you guys getting that stretching effect?? You should be looking at the images, centered in your monitor.

I’m still getting some dramatically huge stretching. Hmm, maybe I’ll ask the listserve people.

Thanks for the input

-Lancelet

Hi there, Kevin (or do you prefer Lancelet)

I would have to agree, number 3 looks the best, 1 does seem somewhat stretched across the nose area, u seem to be having a problem with a seam that runs down the centre of the nose aswell, I’m sure you’ll fix that though.

I remember the first picture you ever posted of the woman in the fantasy clothes, which in my humble opinion was quite good, whatever happened to that on? I find it strange that since then your modelling technique has taken a few steps back, I don’t mean that in a bad way, I just mean that you ask a lot of questions on the best way to model this and model that, and it confuses me after seeing the great work u did on the original fantasy character, I mean that is in it looks like you’ve already got modelling and texturing down, so why ask more questions on plain modelling tasks. I’m actually looking forward to seeing this girl finished, although I think it’ll be a long time coming if your going to keep on posting it again and again, with tiny, tiny minor adjustments. Once, no offense intended, you’ve got some nice stuff there.

James

Hi James.

I prefer to use Lancelet when posting to the forum and Kevin when I use the Listserve. As for my other girl, she’s still there.

http://members.home.net/lancelet/Telaira.jpghttp://members.home.net/lancelet/Telaira.jpg

She was my first human model and was, for all intents and purposes, a test to see how well I could make a human. I didn’t put alot of detail into that one, so that’s one of the reasons why I’m making a this new one. The other reason I’m making this new model is because I’ve never modelled with Polygons or subD’s before, so this time around I’m learning edgeloop techniques which is very different from the way I created my first character. My first character was made from a nurbs sphere and the eyes and nose are seperate pieces that were blended together, so that in itself, is quite a drastically different approach to polygonal modelling a head using edgeloops. Not only is this the first time I’ve used, polygons/subD’s or Edgeloops, but I’m also faced with Heirarchy subD modelling, which is yet another technique which I’m not accustomed to. So what did I do? I modelled the head using hierarchy subD’s and I modeled the body using normal polygonal modelling and subD conversion for smoothing.

Furthermore, this model is all one piece which makes it alot easier for the animating stage of things.

So you see, whenever learning a new technique, I try to do as much research as possible before I begin, hence all of my listserve questions. As for the posts on this forum, I’ve recently been having alot of problems with aspect ratio and this accursed stretching of my images. I’m not 100% sure that people are seeing the head as I’m seeing it, so that in turn can cause them to give misinformed critiques. For instance, I received a few critiques stating that the head was too long and I later found out that the aspect ratio I was modelling at was causing it to look stretched on people running at 4:3 aspect ratios. So I had to repost in order to find out if my head really was too long or if people were looking at it with a different aspect ratio. I actually haven’t worked on the head for the last week, I’ve been concentrating on the body, but I usually don’t make new posts when I do little changes, it’s just that in this case there’s been two big blunders. 1st case was the aspect ratio thingy, which I fixed, and now there’s this problem with screen stretching out the head, which I’ve yet to solve. Anyways, I hope that explains some things for you, and I hope you don’t mean that my new model looks worse than my old one, because I think it looks better. And as for the seam, I’ve stated before that I purposely leave the head in two halves while modelling and doing test renders. I can get rid of the seam at any time, like so.
http://members.home.net/lancelet/Attatched.jpghttp://members.home.net/lancelet/Attatched.jpg

-Lancelet

Hello,

Ah right, that model was nurbs and now your using subd’s! 8)

BTW, that’s pretty darn good for NURBS, I don’t think you’ll have too many problems with subd’s, they’re fairly easy, I’ve been using them in Lightwave for years, or Lightwave’s version of, and they’re pretty similar in Maya (apart from some really irritating stuff, that will be, hopefully, sorted out in Version 4).

Naw, I didn’t mean it looks worse, when I was saying what I said, it was to try and fugure out why on your latest figure, you were asking so many modelling questions, when it seemed like you had already the knowledge in that area, unbeknown to me that you were modelling diffently (subds).

Best

James

I’ll be using LW in the future so that’s another reason I’m building this model. LW doesn’t have Hierarchial SubD’s though, because planning out your parameterization is alot more tricky with hierarchial SubD’s. LW basically only has level 0 edits, if we’re talking in terms of Maya’s Hierarchy subD structure. But I did model the body using LW methodology; that is, I’m not using sublevel edits on the body. I have a clear grasp of it now, but I was totally in the dark when I began.

I like to ask alot of questions, you can’t expect too much from me, I’m still a newbie trying to learn and do alot of things at once. I’m in a classroom of One, and my teachers are the people of the internet, with whom I have no visual contact with, so it makes the learning curve kinda steep if you know what I mean.

-Lancelet

lightwave has a great modeller…you wont be dissapointed by it..

-M-K-

http://homepages.go.com/~ambient_whisper/intro.htmlhttp://homepages.go.com/~ambient\_whisper/intro.html

Hi ,
I would go for either #2 or #3.
the model with eyes closer looks far nicer to me. and i am ok with either slightly longer or shorter face.

these image’s sure look great !!

veeru

Yo Lance…
Excuse my ignorance but what is edgeloops?
This is the first time I hear the term.
I would take girl 3 or 4 (eyes wide apart are considered exotic but in your case I don’t mind either one). What is her name? I want her
How did you start modeling her?
Thanks.

eJekt
eJekted VFX

Edited by ejekt on 01/22/01 01:55:41 AM.

EDGE LOOPS…thats a technique that bay raitt developed. edge loops simulate the muscle structure..so that animating becomes an ease..
heres some stuff for you to read..

http://www.spiraloid.com/tutorial/modeling.htmlhttp://www.spiraloid.com/tutorial/modeling.html

http://www.wingededge.com/news/index.shtml?page=news/derived-surfaces-article/indexhttp://www.wingededge.com/news/index.shtml…s-article/index

http://maxrovat.sns.hu/subdiv/http://maxrovat.sns.hu/subdiv/

-M-K-

http://homepages.go.com/~ambient_whisper/intro.htmlhttp://homepages.go.com/~ambient\_whisper/intro.html

Thanks Ambient. Great links.
So how do you start modeling in order to end up with good edgeloops going? Don’t worry I am reading and testing as I speak, I just wanted to get the question out there for some more feedback. The last link you posted answers the question doesn’t it. Any tips for a Maya user?
Thanks.

eJekt
eJekted VFX

Edited by ejekt on 01/23/01 08:57:37 AM.

actually..i have never made a head that uses edge loops before, so i cant be of too much help to you. sorry.
perhaps lancelet can post up a wireframe…then you could get an idea of how to model using them. or go on the mirai forum and ask.

-M-K-

http://homepages.go.com/~ambient_whisper/intro.htmlhttp://homepages.go.com/~ambient\_whisper/intro.html

#3 looks best