About .hdr images

Has anyone else noticed that despite mrays for maya's
"support" for .hdr images they are only used as ldri
(8 bit) images? floating point TIFF images and .map images seem to be the only file formats that are used as true hdri. interesting, no?

_james
Image Engine

Actually Maya does not support or understand HDR images but MR does as long as they are in the map format.

hey dude, read the post, I typed mental ray for maya , anyway I just thought I'd let people know that despite the fact it's documented that mental ray for maya supports the .hdr format it only uses it as an 8 bit image thus negating the benefits. mental ray only uses the affore mentioned .map format and the floating point TIFF format as true hdri images
thanks

james
Image Engine

Hmm.. well I had not thought about it bein g16bpc per level of exposure but if it is only 8 bpc it still uses the levels of exposure. I'm not familair with working with Mental Ray through other applications . SO is th emap format not capable of being 16bpc?

.map format files work fine as hdri's in Mental ray for maya and so do Floating Point .TIFF's

the .hdr format ends up getting sampled down to 8 bit or clamped or something

If an image is only 8bit per pixel it can't be a High dynamic range image, there isn't enough information per pixel to represent the much larger a range of luminosity, which gives you truely realistic lighting. Using an 8 bit image results in something like that "sky" plugin thats floating around, still very usefull for ambient lighting but not the full meal deal.

_james
Image Engine

I think this is true because If you take an HDR image and convert it to map and compare that render to a version where the HDR has just been saved as a bmp the result is very different. In the latter where the HDR image is saved as a bmp it is most definataly being flattened to an 8 bit image.

Why do you that MR is not taking advantage of the the HDR levels of exposure?

Mental ray can take advantage of HDRI and their full luminance range for image based lighting, it just has to be a floating point image ie not an 8bit perpixel (24 bit) image. so saving a .bmp 8bit image will result in a low dynamic range image. there are several floating point image formats, sgi16, floating point TIFF, .map, .hdr, the newly developed openEXR format and several others but the point is that only .map images and floating point TIFF's work with mental Ray for Maya and in the docs it clearly states that the .hdr format is "supported" but it isn't that's all.

_james
Image Engine

in the docs it clearly states that the .hdr format is "supported" but it isn't that's all.

Do the docs use the .hdr suffix or do they say HDRI? IT's probably just a error in the documentation. I'm assuming than when use MR with XSI that you ahve to covnert to .map as well.

I've personaly found floating point tiffs to be unstable..so i have been sticking to .maps to use with mray. I save an HDR image outta HRDI shop and then use a dos program to make it a .map.. keeping that 16 bit mess.. it seems to work great.