Advice on Graphics Cards

I need some advice on purchasing a stable and fast graphics card for my system. I have an Athlon 1.4Ghz and 512MB RAM and I am looking for a good graphics card to run Maya4. I have a budget of under $600 US Dollars. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Subtillion

Oxygen GVX1 Pro seems to be a good choice if you need solid drivers for professional apps. It’s about 600$. They are talking a lot about GeForce4 too, the 4400 & 4600 models should be amazingly fast. Personally I have a good experience with nvidia chips in terms of performances, but I am soon going to upgrade to something certified with Maya for my work

For $689 (from www.monarchcomputer.com, shop around to get a better deal) you can get much better card, 128MB ATi FireGL 8800. It is the best in the class (mid level 3D pro).

Read the review:
http://www6.tomshardware.com/graphic/02q1/020320/index.html

For a budget card (compared to pro card), get the 128MB GeForce4 Ti4400)

at the same link you listed “http://www6.tomshardware.com/graphic/02q1/020320/index.html” in the addendum it says that after the drivers were updated the Quadro4 750 XGL performed significantly better, you can also get it for under $600 packaged through PNY … so that’s what I purchased and it seems to work great.

Thanks everyone for your posts!

Subtillion

Confused then - does anyone know which card is better for Maya or Alias Studio - the quadro4 750XGL or the firegl8800? Do these two cards represent the best in that general price range?

i had a gvx1- pro and its not worth the money. the glint chipsets are outdated.

Hi,

I just put together a new pc. I had oxygen gvx1 before and i have leadtek geforce 4ti 4400 now, it seems MUCH MUCH faster in 3d apps, also the added bonus of being able to play games too

Also upgraded cpu from p3 650 to p4 2ghz, so i guess that helped a lot too…but manipulating - spinning 3d models etc - is very nice now with all lights on and hardware textures. Also a massive improvement in dynamics playback.

Hello world,
Is anyone using a Wildcat 6220? Is it worth the $$?
-db

Seems gaming cards have prooved they are worth their while, they kick ass in Maya and you can run anything else with them as well.. I have a fireGL in my system right now, and I personally think I made a mistake purchasing it.
hope this helps.

Right now I am running a Dual AMD 1900 MP machine on a Tyan Thunder K7 with 512mb of Registered ECC DDR RAM. I am using a Geforce 3 Ti 200 64mb for a video card. I am starting to get more in to Maya. I am looking at a Quadro4 550GXL for about $250 USD. Is that worth the money? I mean, I see other cards (like the 750GXL) for much more ($600+ USD) all the way up to cards in the $4,000 range. I guess I just don’t really know what I’d see as far as benefits go.

Also, if I do go with a Quadro4 550GXL, how does it work under Linux? Would I get all (or most) of the features out of that card under Linux? Or should I stick with Windows if I want to get the full advantage. I mean, I’m going to go to Linux for a performance gain, but if I am going to lose it on my video card anyway, what’s the point?

Anyway, any answers would be very welcome!

Thanks

stay away from GVX1 Pro - slow for the money Fire gl2 will give you twice the performance, or you can get a wildcat II 5110 fro ebay for about $750

get 6110 - same performance in maya - 60% less dough

900XGL and 750XGL take a huge performance dump on high density scenes
Compared to Fire Gl4 (card of my choice) using maya-test.ma from http://www.maya-testcenter.de/.
On the original test scene results are as follows:

900XGL:
44 f/s wireframe
21 f/s shaded
15 f/s textured
7 f/s text&light
7 f/s light

Fire Gl4:

38 f/s wireframe
19 f/s shaded
12.5 f/s textured
12 f/s text&light
19 f/s light

(both cards tested on the same type of box - Dual Xeons 2.0GHz 2GB RDRAM SCSI RAID L 0 straped U 160 drives, Dual Monitors running 1280X1024 at 75Hz)

The systems reflected a real prod environment setup (no bench mark tweaking)

As you can see, 900XGL didn’t handle lights too well (the card also had hardware overlay planes disabled. When I enabled the planes performance drop was about 35+% - 44 f/s to 29 f/s in wire frame mode).
Fire Gl4 had hardware overlay planes enabled with 8-bit double buffering mode.

A real surprise came when I made scene heavier by instancing all the “flowers” X4 (now scene was 4 times heavier).

Here are the results:

900XGL:

13.8 f/s wireframe
5.7 f/s shaded
3.4 f/s textured
1.8 f/s text&light
1.8 f/s light

Fire Gl4:

17.1 f/s wireframe
6.2 f/s shaded
3.4 f/s textured
3.4 f/s text&light
6.2 f/s light

WOW!
I noticed that Fire gl handles the lights in Maya even better the Wildcat III (in all other aspects wildcat beats Fire Gl4 - well dirextX and Direct 3D support is much better in Fire Gl4)

In conclusion
Looks like XGL series are not yet geered for heavy scenes of the production environment, but it’s price is nice - performance - so so

If you want under $600, I would say get the GeForce 4 ti-4600 hands down. Those cards rock with Maya.

Here’s one of the more expensive of the ti 4600’s.
http://www.vr-zone.com/reviews/Triplex/GF4Ti4600/
(i think you pay more for the casing)

Now that Elsa took a dump, you might be able to find some Elsa Gloria DCC’s for a cheaper price now. I run an ATI Radeon 8500-128 and runs fine for me.

xgl 550
core speed 240 mHz
mem speed 400 mhz
34 mil tri/sec
about the same as one of those modified GF4 MX things which is a modified GF2

compare to the XGL 700
core speed 270 mHz
mem speed 550 mhz
54 mil tri/sec
roughly the same as a GF4 440

the XGL 550 is quieter.
hope the comparison helps

http://www.extremetech.com/print_article/0http://www.extremetech.com/print\_article/0…,a=27268,00.asp

quadros seem to be slower than wildcat in Maya, but still, 7500 sells for less than $600 these days if you shop around.