any fans?

bad link?

Yep -Sorry i sorted it now.

not a fan yet.

any reasons?

Looks good so far, but what is the purpose of this model? Is it for a cartoon? a photo real scene? I notice there are visable poly edges. Also the blades with the current lighting makes them look paper thin… Anyhow it really depends on the render sytle you are aiming for… If it’s for photo real… you have a bit more work to do.

well, reason being that it didnt impress me. Why should it? Not much there, and what is there looks wrong: The shadows are blocky, the materials are elementary and the subject/composition is simplistic (not saying that simple is bad). It didnt please my eye (although it didnt hurt it), it didnt hold my interest and it definately didnt make me have a revelation (or any feelings whatsoever for that matter).
Not even the materials have any character: The base looks like black plastic and the blades look like shait. These materials tell me nothing about the fan (or you); they portray no characteristics for this fan, no history, no nothing. Same goes for the background, lighting, etc. Try to get some feeling in there.
You asked, so there you have it. I suppose I could be nice about it, but what’s the point; the message would still be the same. I got more comments, but this is good for now.
hope this helps,
Gustavo

I dont want to give you the wrong idea, though, because from a design standpoint, I’d say the fan is really quite good. Art aside, the fact that you widen the base towards the bottom, and even accentuate the bottom, is really good (stability). The grill part is stylized, and seems to fit well with the shape of the base. The colors are good for contrast, and they also serve to bring attention to the fan blades (and it’s potential danger).
I’m going to guess that you may have gesign schooling… correct me if I’m wrong.
So, to summarize:
from an art point of view, as in a picture hanging in a gallery: not very good, but I’ve seen much worse.
from a design point of view, as in the style and functuonality of actual objects: almost excelent

I say almost because the grill part doesnt quite offer the optimal amount of protection from those fast moving metal blades; meaning, my colorblind cat might still stick his dumb head through the grill and get his nose choped off. : )

man your rough around the edges Gustavo…

I’m rough around the edges? I guess I dont know exactly what that means.
If you mean I’m harsh, then sorry, but we cant all be as refined as yourself.
Either way, I call them like I see them. Anyone who has their work posted on the professional board should be well capable of withstanding criticism, no matter how harsh, then disect the comment and learn from it if he/she feels that the comment has any useful bits.
If you meant something else by “rough around the edges”, then go ahead and clarify… I might just learn something from it.
good day,
Gustavo