hi, i don't mean to complain. i'm just really frustrated. i'm trying to learn maya, and well, to be honest, i feel that i'm trying VERY HARD. since so many people here praise maya's workflow, i'm sure there's a logical explanation behind it all, and i think that if i heard the logic behind it, it would make the learning experience much more enjoyable. it just seems to me that whatever action i want to take, it inevitably consists of 5 or 6 different actions to get there. for instance, adjusting the tangents of keyframes. in any other application i've ever seen, keyframe tangents are usually automatically weighted. in maya, however, you have to 1) Select the keys 2) choose Keys menu --> Break Tangents. 3) With the tangents still selected, under the Curves menu, choose Weighted Tangents. 4) Move Tool 5) select the handle LMB 6) drag with MMB same goes for breakdown keys, which in many applications is just a matter of selecting the keys, adding a control/option key and dragging on the last key.
another one is rotating the local rotation axis. i thought it would be much the same as editing the pivot location: press the home key, move/rotate, press the home key. done. instead it's (you all know this of course but i'm on a roll here): select the object. 1) f8 for component mode. 2) turn off points. 3) turn on misc. 4) select the axis. 5) select the tab in the attribute editor. 6) set value. 7) and f8 again!!! wow!! or the show manipulator tool, or... like i said, i'd just like to know the logic behind it all. frustration and learning don't mix very well. is it just that maya has SO many options that it has to be so, or i'm i just being difficult, or what?! many thanx, d
Yes, I know your situation and I understand your frustration, but that is the price for using the "Queen Bee" Maya. She produces dazzling results, but the way there is full of stones and pitfalls. Don
Reason is 1 you dont actualy realy want to use weighted tangents at all in most cases. Neither do you wnat to break your tangents since thet usulay makes for bad second derivartre continuity from sample to sample wich is NOT a very desired effect. (noweighted natural splines are faster for maya to calc and they can prettymuch do all that your weighted curves can, especialy if using breakpoints, wich many times is far better than a rewampped tangency)
reason 2 naturaly occouring tangents more closely mimic nurbs wich is what most maya users use exclusively so the connection between theese is better understandable . Also before you tell me tangentted splines are better for drawing forget it, they arent its like saying a straightruler is better than a draftmans spline (wich is a ruler that you can bend ito shape, also incidentaly where splines get their name form).
Anyway its possible to tell maya to automaticaly make broken weitghted tangents by default if you wish, its just not desireable in 99% of cases. (maya tries to force you to work right no matter what).
So even if you have used weighted tangents exclusively in the past does not mean it was the best choise. It might be it was a hinder for you, or might not.
Oh PS: all this said have you ever heard of hotkeys? And yes i must say when i adjust my curves i never actualy do more than 1-2 step of what you describe.
QUOTE(dunkelzahn @ 02/20/06, 04:01 PM) [snapback]228684[/snapback] And that
8i8, just as to your first issue, you can make the tangents on your keys weighted by default. It's in the animation prefs.
Second of all, I totally feel your pain. I'm not just saying that. Maya has had me blue faced and cussing at the monitor many times. Many times.
Also, at the Gnomon site there used to be a tutorial by Alex Alvarez about setting up a marking menu for pick masking that might make your life easier. I haven't used it but you might find it helps with the local rotation axes thing.
hi, thank you for your answers and words of encouragement (and those links as well). i really appreciate it. joojaa, please, how do you get the curves to the exact shape you want them without the weighted tangents? and what do you mean by breakpoints? just did a search but didn't find anything... regarding the MEL, however, i feel i might as well be writing chinese, so i've stayed away from it so far
Each same curve can be made in umlimitted different ways! But this si liek the question about illustratoir user being completely stumped by a nurbs curve and how on earh it can be shaped the same. Well idea is jut to put points in different manner thats all, and qute fankly a nurbs cure is far better once you gat a hang of it.
BUt yes brokeb tangents are allways bad for a nimation siice a tangent wit different vwights on each side of the curve signifies theres some sudden very dramatic change in overall speed at this point. wich quite ffrankly only happens very rarely in real life except on collision.
oh gjuys also when you keyframe in the viewports be sure to use the capital S makingmenu! note the middelemouse allows you to set the tanget type and rightmouse other operations!
By the wqy even mudane shotrcuts like q have mms attached to them as do w e r t a o and shift for example.