Best System For 3d Animators

Hi, I am planning on upgrading my system and would like to ask you a question. If you had up to $3,000 to spend, what would be your dream system excluding the case, monitor and HD?

P4 or AMD? Video Card? Sound Card? Memory? Motherboard?

I mostly use Maya and 3Ds Max, which requires lots of rendering.

Thanks

Some thing like this:

Dual Woodcrest dual core Xeon 2GHz (total 4 cores)
4gb FBD RAM
Intel S5000XVN workstation mb (this is best to be used with Intel SC5299WS chassis)
onboard audio (you shoudn’t need high-end audio card for 3D work)
dual onboard gigabit NIC.
Quadro FX3450 PCI-E video card
DVD burner / floppy drive

about $3k here.

or you can go with:
Intel Core 2 Duo 6700 CPU
4gb DDR2 667 memory
Intel 975 mb
onboard audio (7 channel audio)
onboard gigabit NIC
Quadro FX4500 PCI-E video card
DVD burner / floppy drive

about $3.2k here.

or you can go with:
Intel Core 2 Duo 6700 CPU
4gb DDR2 667 memory
Intel 975 mb
onboard audio (7 channel audio)
onboard gigabit NIC
Quadro FX4500 PCI-E video card
DVD burner / floppy drive

about $3.2k here

This is what I am getting and thanks for the suggestion. It looks real good to me.

QUOTE(TheAnimator @ 09/15/06, 10:43 AM) [snapback]247625[/snapback]
or you can go with:
Intel Core 2 Duo 6700 CPU
4gb DDR2 667 memory
Intel 975 mb
onboard audio (7 channel audio)
onboard gigabit NIC
Quadro FX4500 PCI-E video card
DVD burner / floppy drive

about $3.2k here

This is what I am getting and thanks for the suggestion. It looks real good to me.

Hate to confuse you. but if you could wait a few more weeks, 975XBX2 mb (2nd gen) will support Kentsville CPU. quad-core.

http://www.tomshardware.com/2006/09/10/fou…on\_the\_rampage/

if you look at the last page, you will see 3D rendering (with 3D Studio max) is 100% faster thank Core 2 Duo !!!

QUOTE(bellwilliam @ 09/15/06, 04:49 PM) [snapback]247651[/snapback]
Hate to confuse you. but if you could wait a few more weeks, 975XBX2 mb (2nd gen) will support Kentsville CPU. quad-core.

http://www.tomshardware.com/2006/09/10/fou…on\_the\_rampage/

if you look at the last page, you will see 3D rendering (with 3D Studio max) is 100% faster thank Core 2 Duo !!!

Glad you warned me before my order went through. I understand this does not come out till mid Oct.

Below is what I am planning on getting.

Intel 975XBX2
Core 2 Quad
OCZ Value Series 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 667 (PC2 5400) Dual Channel Kit System Memory Model OCZ26672048V (one thing I do not like about this is no heat spreaders)
PNY VCQFX4500-PCIE-PB Quadro FX4500 512MB GDDR3 PCI Express x16 Video Card (this is pricey $1,799.99 from Newegg)
SAMSUNG 18X DVD

FX4500 at $1,700 is definetely too high. should be $1,300-$1,400.

there is no way you will get Core 2 Quad within a month. First shipment is the week of Nov 16, and it is $1,000 at minimum (more like $1,100). and they are shipping in tray version for the first 4 weeks. retail box version come in mid December.

don’t recommend ATI card for what you are doing. you should go with FX3450 for that price.

QUOTE(bellwilliam @ 09/15/06, 05:47 PM) [snapback]247656[/snapback]
FX4500 at $1,700 is definetely too high. should be $1,300-$1,400.

there is no way you will get Core 2 Quad within a month. First shipment is the week of Nov 16, and it is $1,000 at minimum (more like $1,100). and they are shipping in tray version for the first 4 weeks. retail box version come in mid December.

don’t recommend ATI card for what you are doing. you should go with FX3450 for that price.

Hate to wait that long but it seems like it will be worth the wait after I saw the specs/ results on Tom’s Hardware.

Where did you see the FX4500 going for $1,300-$1,400 if we are allowed to say?

Thanks

Just thought I might throw out another idea:

So much hoopla about single computers now is dual core, dual processor. My main rig is a dual Xeon single core processor (just starting to show its age now). I have not found a reason to upgrade it, but have started spending money on extra rendering boxes (especially since there isn’t a true 64bit, multithreaded OS out yet). I’ve found the dual core processors are about the same as my old dual processor in speed now. I’ve been getting into more complex ray traced effects in MR. I’m not getting a huge change in rendering times, since I’m building my own rendering farm. I just don’t see a justification of spending the ludicrous costs of a high end SLI Quadro card set, dual core, dual processor system, when you could be spending the same money on a series of processors for a rendering farm. Lets face it, the most time consuming thing is rendering. My aging workstation has a Quadro FX 1000 series chipset. I have not had any problems with it…and with Maya 7.0 it’s pretty fast for almost all but the most complex scenes (by complex, I mean a huge 100mb scene file I’m working on). I have found that anything Quadro runs Maya well (the driver sets are always top notch). So for now, it seems like processors is what you should be spending the money on. I think graphics cards are going to change a lot when there’s a real 64 bit PC OS (if Windows Vista ever comes out!!!)

QUOTE(TheAnimator @ 09/15/06, 04:50 PM) [snapback]247657[/snapback]
Where did you see the FX4500 going for $1,300-$1,400 if we are allowed to say?

Thanks

if you check out Ebay (check “complete”), you will see most are selling for about $1k. These are what’s called OEM (from Dell/HP). If you PM me, I will get you a price for non-OEM.

Hi,

I have to agree with Davesrose that having the top of the best in all components are not always necessary.

You mentioned rendering, but keep in mind that for software rendering (maya renderer, Mental Ray) the graphic card does not participate on the process (except if you use hardware accelerated shader like Gelato does). The CPU’s, memory and hard drives make a big difference, the GPU is only important for displaying correctly the viewport.

The benefits of the Quadro range are stability and reliabilty, there’s no question about it.
But having the 1,5K model, if you are not planning to render millions of software particles is not necessary.
Just look at the specs for these cards, tens of millions of triangles and 512 Mb of textures ? How are you planning to render that with your single workstation ?

I would recommend to go for the low/middle range GPU, and use the money you saved in a rendering node, nothing fancy, even a SFF (small form factor) with a dual core CPU and 2 gigs of RAM will save your day.

And if you have some change left, think about silent cooling solutions (CPU, case).
Having 7 computers on my living room, you can trust me, it’s a well placed investment …

Cheers,
Guy.

QUOTE(guy_iti @ 09/18/06, 12:59 PM) [snapback]247849[/snapback]
Hi,

I have to agree with Davesrose that having the top of the best in all components are not always necessary.

You mentioned rendering, but keep in mind that for software rendering (maya renderer, Mental Ray) the graphic card does not participate on the process (except if you use hardware accelerated shader like Gelato does). The CPU’s, memory and hard drives make a big difference, the GPU is only important for displaying correctly the viewport.

The benefits of the Quadro range are stability and reliabilty, there’s no question about it.
But having the 1,5K model, if you are not planning to render millions of software particles is not necessary.
Just look at the specs for these cards, tens of millions of triangles and 512 Mb of textures ? How are you planning to render that with your single workstation ?

I would recommend to go for the low/middle range GPU, and use the money you saved in a rendering node, nothing fancy, even a SFF (small form factor) with a dual core CPU and 2 gigs of RAM will save your day.

And if you have some change left, think about silent cooling solutions (CPU, case).
Having 7 computers on my living room, you can trust me, it’s a well placed investment …

Cheers,
Guy.

I have thought about that and might go for the lower Quantro model. I am currently using a Prometeia Mach 2 GT and already have four other computers in the house . One thing for sure is that I am going to get the new Duo Quad CPU and 975XBX when it comes out. The other parts does not have to be the best.

Thanks

Does anyone know the exact date the Intel 975XBX2 is supposed to come out to the stores? Thanks

QUOTE(TheAnimator @ 09/29/06, 12:43 PM) [snapback]248865[/snapback]
Does anyone know the exact date the Intel 975XBX2 is supposed to come out to the stores? Thanks

1st week of November is the ship date. don’t know when it will hits the stores. Intel is waiting for it to release at about the same time as Kentsfield (quad-core).

QUOTE(bellwilliam @ 09/29/06, 02:07 PM) [snapback]248867[/snapback]
1st week of November is the ship date. don’t know when it will hits the stores. Intel is waiting for it to release at about the same time as Kentsfield (quad-core).

Thanks for answering. Not sure if I want to wait that long heh

I might just get the following parts. I think it will be good enough for a year or two.

Intel Core 2 Duo 6700
Intel 975XBX
Quadro FX4500 PCI-E video card

Just one more question. Which brand of Memory I should get? I am not sure because the timings varies with different companies. I am looking to get either 2G or 4G. Thanks

QUOTE(TheAnimator @ 09/29/06, 01:26 PM) [snapback]248870[/snapback]
Thanks for answering. Not sure if I want to wait that long heh

I might just get the following parts. I think it will be good enough for a year or two.

Intel Core 2 Duo 6700
Intel 975XBX
Quadro FX4500 PCI-E video card

Just one more question. Which brand of Memory I should get? I am not sure because the timings varies with different companies. I am looking to get either 2G or 4G. Thanks

price of memory has been going up everyday. so don’t be too picky on the brand (as long as they are name brands). just find an e-tailer who still might have old inventory, so you can get a good price.