I was told you can't get a Bokeh light effect in mray as yet. Brazil seems to be able too, after seeing the info in anarticle. It certianly seems to lend to a very nice realistic apperance to night shots.
Anyone know if that is hidden in Mray or on the way to it?
Just kinda curious.
been looking around...guess not eh? haha by the silence for this thread I'm guess its an emerging idea.
Is Bokeh a real word?
Very real.....indeed,
A Japanese word that has been adopted as the term for "out of focus blur quality" of a camera lens.
Probably pronounced "bow-keh", "Bow" sound as in bow and arrow and "keh" sound as in Kevin.
When a lens is focussed on a subject, the image on the film of that subject should be sharp. Depending on the depth of field chosen by means of lens focal length and aperture, details behind and in front of the subject will be out of focus to some degree on the film.
If a highlight, like sun reflecting off a rain drop on a leaf, or a distant bright light in a night scene, starts to unfocus then it may adopt unusual forms. The nominal small point of light starts to spread out more into a bigger, blurry disk as it is unfocussed more and more. Now it is the quality of this big blurry disk that gives the lens its Bokeh. With mirror lenses this unfocussed spot becomes a doughnut instead of a disk. In a "perfect" lens the focussed point of light becomes an evenly bright large soft disk when unfocussed, the "perfect" lens does not necessarily have the best Bokeh.
its a methoud to get the lens effect of that blown out light in 3d..Brazil has implamented it somewhat....no other renderer has so far.
Oh...yeah I didn't know there wa a word for that..
these kind of effects are best done in the comp. Bokeh, DOF, other lens effects, all should be done in post, with few exceptions.
I used quite a lot of that Bokeh type of thing, usually very subtle and not highly out of focus, on my last film project "Stuart Little 2". Always done as a filter in the compositing package.
So even if the renderer had supported it, it didn't support Bokeh but did support DOF, we wouldn't have used it. It's too slow and ties you in to an effect that can't be adjusted without a complete, very slow, re-render. In the comp, it's more-or-less interactive.
Is it a filter than creates Bokeh in post or is their a general technique for getting sthose roundish blurs?
I agree with you that in a comp it might be nicer.
In a 3d render it might be nice to have a Bokeh render pass though and have it as a seperated layer...
Alhtough.
I havn't gotten a good,realistic, Bokeh effect at all in post with the filters I have onhand..
It seems to me for a post filter to work correctly, you;d have to be able to selece a color tempture range or a lumance value range for the effect to ..well..effect..
and i do not know of any that sophisticated. though i am sure they exist since people do pull it off.
any advice?
it's a filter that does it. A circle of convolution filter, or something like that. It blooms the highlights. You can probably get a similar effect with:
a lumakey (isolate the highlights),
then a dilate (grow the selection) ,
then a gaussian blur (blur the details)
then screen them back atop the original (or just replace the original element).
So, in other words, you could probably make a macro of all the operators to speed this up.
Shake also has circle or polygonal highlight blurring in one operator.
Yes Allso the advantage of doing this in post is that its faster to do, fater to tweak... Wihle on the downside its not physicaly as correct (or actualy thats debatable as long as the pass you use renders the relevant info).
thanks Martin, I've gotten close in the past using similar methouds..but its that kinda color shift. that reflection off the lens or whatver mirco crud in on there and the true circular bloom you just never get like acual shot footage..and honestly.. looking at examples of the 3d solution..they are kinda a ways off too..
thanks man, one day we will be able to perfectily mimch phootgraphy easily ..haha I think. Getting closer, for 99% of purposes the post mthoud is beleiveable. I was just curious.
well actualy the crud could easily be added in post!
clearly the post method isn't perfect, but I think it probably passes the production tests of: being fast, being highly adjustable, and being good enough.
The 3d method fails maybe 2 out of 3 of those tests. At least for animation purposes and still doesn't look "right". So I guess for stills the 3d method might be applicable but the render times I've seen for these kinds of effects have been absolutely horrendous.
From my own experience in feature films, physical accuracy is not an asset. In fact, we break the rules of physics radically all the time.
acualy you;re 100% right, all it takes is the audieance to suspend there disbeleif and go.. ok cool. And never get taken out of that reality,.
I was only mentioning it as one of those..."how real can I get" lines of though. The fact is, some stuff that is reality doesn;t look right at all when yoiu create it .
Ever see somthing in real life that you basacaly said..thats so not right .but yet, thats what it looks like.
Yes ive ran across this many times... people telling me
Ever see somthing in real life that you basacaly said..thats so not right .but yet, thats what it looks like. <
Oh sure. Reality or physically correct is often quite boring or just not good for the composition or story we are trying to tell.
I used to kind of laugh when Mental Ray was always promoting itself on how "physically correct" it was. I just kept thinking how that might be great for science purposes but wasn't going to be appreciated in the entertainment business.