Please chew me up and critisize it all because I want to learn. Some of the chess pieces had what looked like a seam or a line down one side (see bishop in 2nd pic), which I assume is a result of the lathe (or revolve in Maya) function of 3ds Max but was not sure.
Software: 3ds Max
Render: Standard 3ds Max renderer
First of all, I agree with Joojaa, a chessboard is to common and boring, sorry.
Seccond, please make the background not black, you can’t see your chesspieces (if that is the word, I’m Durch) good enough. Make a room or something with this board standing on a table or something like that.
I agree with both of you - a chessboard is boring to the seasoned CG artist, but for one just learning - it was a simple test to learn some basics. Thank you for the input - I was only doing the chessboard for reference and basics, so I will not play with a scene just yet…
(the above being said…) try putting a texture on the specular, make the pieces not soooo smooth. Also you can light it with a few lights like a war key light a cool dimmer light from another direction, like that it might be cool. the actual board it very very clean. the wood is all on cut it probably would be glued out of 4 pieces of wood. your textures are not all going the right way. the checkard part, could use a little diffuse or something to make it not so stark.
And don’t worry about posting something that is cliche or that others have done we’ll still help you, just keep at it and try as hard as you can to observe the real world and bring that to your work.
Thank you destruct007 - that is the type of criticism that I was looking for. I will work on these aspects. And no, I am not worried about seasoned 3d artists commenting about “yet” another chessboard. I am sure they had done their “another” project at some point…
FIX YOUR ALIASING! Sorry, but jaggies stab me in the eye. Super sample your glass surfaces and change your aliasing filter to something like Mitchell or Lancos.
Your seam is simply unwelded points. If you’re lathing, you’ve got a “Weld Seam” checkbox. Check it. If you’re still getting problems, lathe it, drop it to edit mesh/poly and go weld the points manually.
You’ve got pinching on the bottom of all of your pieces (where too many polys intersect in one place). Grab your spline pre-lathe and pull the tension so it isn’t perfectly flat (and hence forces more loop polys to be built and aid in the hiding of the pinch).
So, in summary… Weld points, fix pinching. Other than this, thumbs up
SnIpeR_83 - thank you very much for your notes. This is the kind of cirtique that I can use. I will review the scene as soon as I have time for some of your ideas.
I think that the modeling is quite acceptable but the staging is too harsh… too, well, black and white. You need to put this chessboard somewhere. Soften the lighting on it (in the studio we’d use a great big softbox) and then kiss it with a little bit of specularity to give it shine .. but not too much shine .. and edge definition. Right now you are using directional, specular lighting as your primary light source, and that just doesn’t fly. Not in a photograph, and not in CG. I also advise that, while the chesspieces can be drippy-specular, the board beneath them ought not be.
All forms of visual media have very narrow limits as to the amount of contrast they can handle… When you spruce-up the presentation and work more within the limits of the (display) technology, I think you’ll find that this picture looks a whole lot better without a single bit of re-modeling. (Even real-glass chesspieces often show mold-lines.)
Thank you, sundialsvcs and destruct for the information. sundialsvcs - your critique is very helpful and I appreciate your time to let me know. I will consider your points for this scene (when I freakin have time to go back to it - work has been a bi***).
destruct - what is SD tv? sorry, not to knowing of things…
sd means standard definition. in PAL world it means your final image will only be 720 pixels wide and 576 down (divided by two for fields). Basically, there would be so little image information left that you probably wouldn’t notice the pinching.
In ntsc you’d be lucky to notice the chess pieces at all