Degree project - char animation

ok so technically i’m not a student any more but this was a piece of character animation i done for my final year degree project.

Can you guys have a look to see what you think of it. I’m uncertain as to wether or not potential employers would be impressed with this. If not then i’ll probably start a new project.

Bear in mind that this is purely character animation, no speech, no spectacular lighting or texturing (hence the toon render ). Unfortunately there are some things which i didn’t have time to implement such as sound and the film grain effect. It’s supposed to look like old film, that’s why it’s black and white except without the effect

Download from my site www.andyshome.eclipse.co.uk

Enjoy… / me dons fire proof suit

As a student myself, I can’t offer a professional oppinion. But I’ll share what thoughts I have.

First off, it’s a project of moderate scope and you finished it. Congrats on that. I know that in my own experience that it is hard as a student to follow a project all the way through to the end.

Personally I like the look of the piece. I like the clean, simple geometry. But I spotted at least one graphical error that needs correcting, and my gut feeling is that the animation needs another round of tweaking if that is your intended focus.

Specifically:

  1. Watch the magician’s right arm (on our left) as he pulls the second rabit out of the hat. It’s stuck solid; on a stepped key or something. Same deal when the magician has been sucked down into the hat and the hole is closing above him; he comes to a freeze-frame stop.
    In general this is a big no-no. The rule is, never let any part of your character come to a full stop (except the feet I guess); instead use ‘moving holds’ where the motion tapers to a near halt, but never ceases completely. This will help keep the spark of life constant in your character.
  2. After the magician is sucked into the hat, his landing after the fall is very stiff.
    When he looks back up towards the hole, in dismay, his mouth is open – but it doesn’t read properly because the lighting has not provided enough shadows to describe the shape of the mouth. I suggest applying a slightly darker shader to the mouth interior to define its outline.
  3. When the magician runs away from the giant boot, look at the way he runs. Again, it looks stiff and could use some work.
  4. When the magician encounters the other magician in the white coat, he jumps back with a start – but he somehow evades inertia and doesn’t keep moving backwards; instead he falls back into his original position… you’re going for a springy type of effect I see… but something about it isn’t quite up to par. Either go with a more conventional physics, or keep playing with your springy motion till it reads better.

Now, having made my criticisms, let me say, I think you should stick with this project and tune it up rather than starting a new one.

You have on your hands a complete story, with rigged characters (or at least one rigged character) and all the shots set up. That is a powerful advantage. If you start another project you go back to square one – and start all over doing the modeling and rigging and doing all of the other chores that get in the way of animation. If you want to prove that you can animate, you are in an ideal position to hone your skills on the tools you have already set up.

I say, instead of restarting, you break this thing down and go over it again with a fine toothed comb, and spend all of your time focusing on just the animation; some parts you will be able to keep. Others you can improve. In the end you could have one very polished piece, which is better than two rough pieces on a demo reel, I would imagine.

Btw… the part at the beginning where the magician is getting sucked down into the hat: that part, as they say, is “money”. It works. The timing of the action is quick and punchy, with good, short holds at just the right moments, and the whole character is moving; never a complete freeze. You even managed some squash and stretch - either in maya or in post; I can’t tell which. Impressive. Try and hold on to the level of action you achieved there, and fill it out into the rest of the piece. If you can do that, I bet you will fare well in your job search.

Good luck and best wishes!

Oh. And put some music to it or something. I understand that some employers turn off the sound when viewing reels (to concentrate on the graphics) but for those that don’t, I suspect a silent project will have a hard time competing with the full blown audiovisual acts around it.

Over all i enjoyed the piece. The impact with the fall is rather flat as previously mentioned. Also the run feels really stiff and lacks fluidity.

I too would fine tune this piece rather than starting over from scratch. The additional hours you put into it will serve you well. Besides, after another week or so when it is done, yeah for the 2nd time, you can start on that OTHER idea you have rolling around in your head and you can give that life.

Best,

john

Thanks for your opinion.

Very detailed analysis nonquad I’ll try and keep those points in mind.

Keep the comments coming.