I am working on an animation involving an electric chair. I am aiming for photorealism - and I am going to composite a live-action character into the chair. Since I’m mostly interested in the compositing - and not very good at the 3d aspect - I would like to have your comments on my 3d work. It can be found on:
A photoreastic anim? one thing is for sure, you have picked a very delicate theme for your work. Personally I find the subject too up to date, the blood is still warm.
But anyway, not much feedback to give since it’s wip, meaning it’s OK, the obvious things of course, such as increase the tesselation for the wires, sort your lights and so on, which you’r going to do anyway.
The most jarring aspect of the image as-is is the procedural wood texture. Never, never, never use one of those in a finished product where the wood makes up any significant portion of the surface. Get some authentic wood textures and slap them on–and make sure to add some bump and spec. You’ll be glad you did.
aside from what shydo and steve said, (listen to them as they are wise men) It’s looking pretty good. I like it alot and i think you could definately pull this off. One thing that will definately kill the realism is how tesselated the wires are. this should be super easy to fix, so don’t dispair.
This might be some tricky lighting to pull off. It all depends on what look you’re going to go for. the lighting that you’ve got there now is not bad, but it’s nowhere near as moody as it should be. Also, keep in mind that you don’t have to do all of the lighting in one pass. Since you’re a compositor, you might try playing with a few different setups. Here’s an example of what I mean:
Let me make something clear, I’m not a pro and I suck at lighting, but i figured out that I could achieve the look that i was going for with a simple dirty photoshop trick. (you can also use after effects, of course) I don’t know if this will help you, but who knows, it may.
have fun!
-Jake
Thank you very much for you comments… very helpful. I will adjust these things right away - and then post a new (hopefully better) image later.
Regards
Allan
PS. The guy in th chair will be white (irish, actually). The story is anti-deathpenalty - but the theme isn’t really about death penalty, but rather of love and loss. But the thing is that you really can interpret it the way you want. Confused? So am I… but hopefully it will all work out in the end
(1) The wiring looks a little thin for the large currents that must flow through them. Are you basing this on actual photos? If not I would make them thicker guage. Perhaps have nuts and bolts for attaching wires to fixtures, like a Dr. Frankenstien movie.