hey guys, this is my first facial animation, i was hopeing to get some feed back on it…i can point out a million things wrong with it : ) but hopefully i can get some insight on how to fix the problems… the clip is from clockwork orange by the way.
www.unspokenvibe.comtalk2.avi
This animation is very difficult to critique for two reasons. First, the wireframe is incredibly distracting. It’s useful to post a wireframe if you’re looking for modelling tips, but for animation like this, it just gets in the way. Second, the clip is too short–there’s really not room for much to happen.
That said, for such a short clip, I think you tried to cram too much in. I would recommend you focus on a basic pose for the character, and figure out ONE bit of the dialogue that you really want to accent with your animation. Animate around that moment. Don’t incorporate broad movement into all parts of the face all through the dialogue (esp. the brow)–you lose any sense of emphasis and your character’s face feels like it’s got a mind of its own.
Even though it’s obviously just an exercise, you should animate the whole head, not just the features. Head movement is an important aspect of expression and communication.
I want to see more pursing of the lips for the word ‘cured,’ and a smoother movement through ‘all right.’ Right now it’s a bit awkward there.
Good luck with it.
-Steve
thanks for your comments…i actually had one without the wire frame…dont know what happened to it. The brows were a little out of control. I did that at like 2 in the morning though…couldnt wait to get something animated : ). I did another one from a gladiator clip. www.unspokenvibe.com/glad2.wmv This time i gave him some head movement and toned down the brow movement quite a bit. Still needs some work but i think im learning a lot. once again i appreciate any comments anyone has to give. even little short comments are good. whether you like it or not.
This one is much easier to digest.
For me, the sync is off by a significant amount–maybe half a second or so. Could it be an encoding error?
Two main tips. First, don’t have the head drift so constantly. Once it reaches a pose, it should pause for a while before going on to the next. Second, don’t over-animate the mouth. Even with the sync off, I can tell you’re trying to make sure you animate the mouth position for every single sound in the words. In reality, we make fewer mouth positions than you’d think. Tone it down and err on the side of smoothness rather than detail.
Animating those eyes will really help, too.
Good work. Good luck with it.
-Steve