Hi there,
I am testing out the Furnace wire-removal tool on my 2k plates. I really like the results. Though there are couple of things that I dont quite understand. Maybe somebody could help me out.
My first question is about the loglin conversion. I work with log cineon plates. If I use a loglin conversion then I get quite a contrast in the removed area. As if I have sharpened that part. If I just work in log without any linear conversion the exact opposite happens. I get more of a blurred area which looks funny enough much better specially if I compare the blue channels to look better at the grain.
So I changed the rDGamma in my LUT and it ended up being almost on 0.2 to make it look "ok". Can somebody tell me why that happens and what would happen really if I dont use the loglin conversion?
Now when I use a difference key to compare the output result with the original scan I see that a much larger area than my wire-matte has been modified. The pixels are "softer". Thats another thing that I dont understand since I dont know really what the tool is doing internally.
If someone could kick my braincells here - I would be verrrry thankful!!
Are you working in 16 bit or float?
QUOTE(beaker @ 01/04/06, 06:49 PM)
Are you working in 16 bit or float?
[snapback]223955[/snapback]
I work in float- I added the bytes node before the loglin and after the linlog I went back to 16bit
QUOTE(grasshoppa @ 01/04/06, 09:54 AM)
I work in float- I added the bytes node before the loglin and after the linlog I went back to 16bit
[snapback]223961[/snapback]
Don't put a bytes node to go back to 16 bit on the way out(after the loglin). Your clamping your color when you do that. 32 bit float will fit into a 10 bit cineon log file just fine.
Hi grasshoppa!
Without going too deep - the WireRemoval node starts off with a soft repair and gradually re-introduces more and more high-frequency information (usually the grain). The control for this is the detailLength control. When set to 0, this should give you a very soft repair. As you raise it to higher and higher values (6 being my favourite, for some reason) then the grain starts to reappear in the repair.
After a little playing, you'll soon get the idea of what values give you back everything that isn't wire, without starting to bring the wire itself back.
The filtering that puts information back onto the soft repair is going to behave differently depending on the contrast of the input, so I'd expect it to behave differently depending on whether you LogLin or not first. Or, to put it another way, the detailLength setting is probably going to be different depending on whether you work in log space or not. If you leave the setting along, it may prove to be too soft in one space and too 'hard' in the other.
The next thing is the repair outside the matte region. This looks like a bug. I'll get The Foundry support team to log it. However, it's most apparent on my example here if you have the sincFilter option turned off. The sincFilter option should usually be on - there's very few things that look better with it off, although leaving it off does speed up processing. while you're trying to tune the wire position and width settings.
If there's something specific about your footage that still seems wrong to you, then we'd be happy to set you up with an ftp location at The Foundry where you could let us see a frame (or a fragment of it, if the full content needs to be withheld). Let me know!
Best wishes
Simon
QUOTE(grasshoppa @ 01/04/06, 07:18 AM)
If I use a loglin conversion then I get quite a contrast in the removed area.
I see that a much larger area than my wire-matte has been modified.
Thanx Beaker for pointing that out! Was almost about to make this stupid mistake.
Hello Simon!
Thank you very much for your response and also for the offer to send you the footage. You have answered my questions and couple of things are clearer to me. Right now I dont have access to my testscripts anymore but if I manage to get permission I would like to get back to you. I will let you know. Thank you again!!
best regards!!