I’ve been having a very difficult time deciding which between the VX1 and the ErazorX2 I should buy (I only have a budget for these cards).
As far as I’ve noticed, the Geforce DDR has 3 problem areas in Maya; Image Planes, Artisan and PaintFX due to the absence of Hardware Overlaying.
I can overlook Artisan and PaintFX but what worries me is the sluggishness while using Image Planes that people have been complaining about. Image Planes are important to me because I want to be able to model with reference images.
I know that the GeForce’s raw power leaves the VX1 trailing behind…but if the lack of overlays causes it to be unworkable then I will choose the VX1.
I have no experience with these problems so can anyone who has shed some light on these issues. Are these problems tolerable? I don’t have much money so I have to make sure I’m buying the right product. Thanks in advance.
Well, I dont have a geforce,
I have a vx1,
and yes, the image planes/artisan etc work just fine
and dandy,
but it can slow down if I use a HUGE file for an image
plane, like I was trying to test it to see if it’s sluggish,
and used like, a 30mb bitmap,
it slowed down a bit, but wasnt very bad.
I think pretty much, if you get a geforce, you should
be able to make a compressed .jpeg version of your
imageplane, which will make the filesize alot smaller,
and therefor make it quicker.
But i duno, thats just a suggestion,
as i said, i dont have a geforce, so i dont know if that’l work.
File size won’t help the redraw issue by compressing it with jpeg. To display a jpeg you have to decompress it to dump it to the framebuffer. Its not a memory issue. I wish nvidia and other companys would get their collective head out of their ass and do proper support for overlays. Considering the POS Indigo 2 Solid impact by my feet can pull it off and that hardware is years old. Sigh.
Anyways a way around the issue is to draw a curve/spline template of the reference image and then turn off the image leaving the spline curves.. save it into a template layer and you eliminate the need [for most issues] for image planes on low end 3d hardware.
HI there! just dont worry too much about it,go for a gforce , before i got a quadro and a gforce i was using a wildcat 4000 and i tell you it moved as fast as the gforce and quadro the image planes,its not slow if you are using medium side pictures,but if you need speed for modeling as template there is a quick trick i use to get full speed redraws:
select the camera you wanna use the template and make a simple copy of it(so if you are using right view copy right view) then use in this copy the image plane,and make sure display in all views is selected,well thats it,use the original right view as reference (not the one you put the image plane in) youll have the imageplane there as template at full speeds redraws.
Hope this help! anyway,dont doubt it GET A GFORCE! they rock!!
Un zaludo,Mikel!
pd:sorry my bad english [img]http://www.highend3d.com/boards/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/sad.gif[/img]
I used asus gforce6600 before I get a elsa gloria2,untill
now,the imageplane of gforce ia as good as quadro by my
experience.so dont hesitate,GO FOR A GFORCE!it’s so fast
as quadro!
I have the same problem with slow image planes, but I have a different way of working around it.
The perspective view with image planes has fast redraws, so I just use the persp view and rotate it to be oriented the way I want. This gives me full redraw speed, but is of course far from the ideal solution.