Good enough vid card?

Hey everyone!
I haven’t posted in a long while.
I’m currently building a “good enough” workstation while I’m residing here in japan for a bit and I wanna keep working on some animation and texturing. nothing too crazy but too keep up my skills.
I currently have a P4 2.4 and 1Gb of ddr.

I was thinking about getting a GeForce 4 of some kind but if anyone has any better suggestions? I’ve been out of the hardware loop for a couple years. I’d also like to have a video out so I can watch dvds on the tv.

btw: I’m using Maya 4.5

thanks everyone!

phred.
Osaka/Kyoto

Hi!

I don’t suggest you to buy a Geforce. Gef4 MX is almost equal to Gef2 MX, and ATI Radeon9700Pro beats Gef4 Ti4600 (or what) to a frazzle. But R9700 is not cheap, but you can get an R9500 which can be upgraded to R9700PRO with driver hack. And it’s much more good for games too. But with Maya… hmm, maybe not the best bacause I cannot use it for HW render in Maya 5. (I explained it in a later topic in this forum). But if you use Maya 4.5 then you cannot use HW render, so you won’t see this inconvenience.

Dexx

Hrmm
I typically steer clear of ATI cards for workstations; even the fast 9700. It may wipe the floor with just about everything else; but speed doesn’t mean much when you go to renderview and maya crashes on you.

I don;t know why anyone would recomend a ATI card over Nvidia, Nvidia works with all the software companys and has strong ties to both MS and Apple. So why would you think they didn;t have supieror drivers and support? I mean if ATI was cheaper , maybe, but really why bother?

thanks for the info! I’ve never really had good experiences with ATI cards in general so I’m not in a big hurry to get one. but maybe the radeons are indeed better, I dunno. just that ATI doesn’t seem like a high end brand to me.
but anyhow the list I have so far is:

GeForce 750XGL, 4600ti or the 4200ti. mayhaps the radeon 9500

however I checked the qualifications on the alias site and they don’t recomend the GeForce series at all. hmm… looks like some more research. but maybe the XGL series… I’ll see how much the quadro series is out here… is it worth it?

You can pick up a quadro 750XGL from googlegear.com for around 350 USD
Its definately a good card. I certainly like the beast.

hey someone delete this post Its redundant

You can pick up a quadro 750XGL from googlegear.com for around 350 USD
Its definately a good card. I certainly like the beast.

Whats more; its qualified hardare and rock solid.

Look. The driver part is ok. NVidia has more mellow drivers eg. for Maya. But actually I don’t watch only 3D application. I play games as well. And for games R9700Pro is much more better than NVidia’s any car. Look: R9700Pro has been dumped more than one year !!! And only NVidia’s FX5900 can beat this card, but this card has been dumped in only about a few monthes !!! So ATI was at the stage more than 1 year ago where NVIdia is now… And look at the FX series… I wouldn’t pay a pound for them… Didn’t you hear the HW crashes? They warm too much, and HW melts…

And the driver hack for FX? Where the driver recognizes if the 3DMark2003 benchmark runs, and it manually configures the card to get more points for benchmark to the stupid user think that it’s better than ATI’s R9700Pro card?? Because this is the only way to beat it… Because FX is melted into thin air…
And this driver hack is esclandre…

So Nvidia is goind down…

And ATI crash? I have never had system crash with this R9700Pro. However when I had a Get2GTS I had to check all of the detonator drivers in order to find one which doesn’t crash my system randomly in 1-2 hours! So this is the crash report…

My ONLY and one tourble with Radeon is with a driver hacking, because I cannot use it as a FireGL X1 with hacked drivers for Maya’s HW render. And my friend, who has a Gef2MX can use it with hacked ->Quadro drivers, but this is the only part where ATI has an inconvenience. In everything else ATI beats NVidai…

Dexx

sigh
I figured all this maschazna would find its way here eventually

Games don’t sign paychecks there guy.

Okay; that doesn’t change the fact that ATI’s openGl implimentation sucks.. for every 1 person that says maya runs great and dandy on a 9700 i can find 20 that find it crashing or unable to do basic functions. In fact most people that say the 9700 works great in maya are people that open the program; make a cube; then close it.
Hell one guy I know did a comparison with a 9500 vs a geforce4 MX in XSI. The GF4 was way faster with dense models.. ATI doesn’t make these things to do anything but rasterize game frames.

Hrmm.. never heard a case where one melted. Besides I’m not even recommending the 5800 ultra (has to be the card your talking about) but a quadro 750XGL. I previous gen card that WILL outperform your 9700 in applications. Also if you don’t run that screensaver, the hardware runs very solid.
But its irrelevant now since nvidia phased it out and replaced it with the 5900 which is faster and runs no hotter than your precious ATI board.

The 3dmark “hack” as you put it has absolutely ZERO berring on how the card will perform in maya. Also in testing this driver I find it to be fairly solid in dealing with things in maya AND in video games. As for the FX melting in thin air thats probably some more strangeness you’ve fabricated..

Its good to see the ATI fanboy riffraf has discovered the world of high end 3d… wonderful. On this point I hate to say it but nvidia isn’t going anywhere. If you understood anything about the video card industry, or the semiconductor industry, or even how to run a lemonaid stand. You’d know nvidia is firmly entrenched and the fastest card has nothing to do with who holds the greater market share.

Sounds like your a fantastic tech. Having been through every generation of nvidia card for work machines I’ve not found fault in any of them. Few people here have, and the ones that do are ussually swiftly resolved. So just because you have all manarisms of issues with 1 card (that was probably defective anyway) doesn’t suddenly make the 9700 the ultimate workstation card.

That and overall application performance. I’ve seen the X1 give display errors with 3dsmax of all things. I’ve NEVER seen a card give a display error in max until I saw them bench the X1.
Thats quite a feat.

ATI just does not develop the openGL end of their drivers and applications like maya suffer for it.

If you want to use the hardware renderer I suggest you use qualified hardware. If you want to play video games then don’t plan on using the hardware renderer.

Its as simple as that.

(a quick note; theres issues with the X1 if you check the release notes; I guess ATI isn’t as great as you thought)

acualy I agree , seriously, why bother with ATI ?
Nvidia is in bed with most of the software manufactures, there openGL 2.0 implamtation so far is flawless, they have enough money to seriously spend it on R and D . plus they beleive in R and D.
I’m all for whatever works, and so far Nvidia has been doing it for me since they came out.