ok, i want to build a workstation for editing (pinnacle studio dv), compositing (combustion) and 3D (Max)…
well, i know that an all in one box isn
assuming intel can get over its legal issues involving the itanium and itanium 2’s (currently under an injunction by intergraph for patent infringements)
you still won’t be baraged with marketting info from that CPU.
to answer your question
MP’s aren’t that much more expensive than the XP’s and would probably be your safer bet. Of course I’m doing just fine with a single CPU box at my home; but thats just me.
I would go for the highest memory bandwith since it’s what counts in the applications that you mentioned.
Dual Processor are indeed faster but only for batch rendering (Combustion or StudioMax).
For previewing in Combustion, RDRam is a lot better than DDRam (I’ve had both and my current workstation is much better)
Depending on how important rendering is for you, I would get a Single Pentium 4B (2.53 is quite cheap nowadays) with 1 gig of Rambus PC1200 or even better Rimm 4200 and a matching motherboard ( I personnaly recommend Asus P4T533 or P4T533-C knowing that the first one is a little faster but uses the most expensive Ram you can get (Which happens to be the fastest also)
This configuration is what I currently have and I’m very happy with combustion and Studio Max.
An other thing, it would be a good idea for combustion and DV editing to have a raid controller (included on the mobo) and 2 good identical harddrives (8mb of cash if you can afford them). This is a must have too for Video or serious audio work. I’m happy with mine and they can substain uncompressed dv res without dropping frames. (something you can’t do with a normal controller)
If you need more detail I’ll answer ya
Dave
hmm,
that ol
russell,
how does your system look like ?
and here in europe a 1900xp costs almost half of an 1900 mp (well the 1900 will die out soon anyway…)
anyone working stable with overclocked cpu
It depends where you live.
In the states you wouldn’t have to shell out a lot of money for it.
Go to www.pricewatch.com and start from there.
I’m only saying this because P4 is getting a lot cheaper than what it used to be. It’s getting close to Amd in term of price. I wouldn’t have recommended a P4 one year and a half ago. Intel processors are also very stable with these applications.
Even ILM chose P4 as their new processor and dropped Silicon Graphics.
Going for a dual MP isn’t a bad choice either.
Whatever you choose, you’ll be happy with it.
As for the harddrives, get at least 2 ATA 100 7200rpm.
You’ll be happy with this too.
By the way, about overclocking processors, I have a P4 2.4B running at 145 FSB (2.62Ghz). It’s the highest stable speed I was able to reach. I also have the fastest memoty settings .
Basically, if you want to overclock, you need to invest in a decent case with several fans and a good heatsink (Intel’s default one is fine but you can get better if you can pay for it like Alpha, Thermalright…)
overclocking is kinda like..
how fast can i make this Yugo go until the wobble blows me off the highway ?
You find the maximune safe edge.
Sure..its not stable, but you havn’t crashed yet.
hey,
so this is what i
I guess that I will chime in on this for input:
I currently have a AMD XP 1800 with a 40 gig drive and a 80 gig drive. Works well. The new 8 meg cahe Maxtors at 7200RPM. The problem I have is in the RAM. I am set at 512 now of the PC2100. Soon to be 3 Gigs of 2700 (333mhz) ram. I notice a difference over the dual processor that I use as well (more on that later) I also have a dual setup on my AMD with video cards. I use the GeForce 3 ti500 (decent but want a true dual display card) and then the PCI Radeon 7500 for the other. Running XP Pro as well. Works well with most apps, but with Maya it will kick me when I drag the other tools into the second monitor. Photoshopa nd all Adobe/compositing tools work pretty much flawless. I do notice a HUGE difference in video playback from this to my Dual Pentium 3 gigahertz machine that is running 2 gigs of ram. It will not drop at all from what I can tell and I use it to batch render larger animations, etc. Works a lot better. The video card is the GeForce 2 64 meg Pro card. I LIKE GAMES! ![]()
Hope this helps out with the choices. From what a buddy of mine at Boeing says, Pentiums are better, but it is all how you spec it out! Go dual if ya can. I wish that my AMD was just that!
Later!
hey inteldoc,
hmm, i