I am in a 3d class this semester and I need to have access to Maya besides just our computer lab. My question is, I don’t know if it works as well as it does on the pc.
I have a dual 1GHZ G4 with 1.75GB of ram and the Radeon 9000 Pro video card. On Maya’s site, it lists some “known problems” as:
You may encounter the following on Jaguar systems (10.2.x):
The texture placement manipulator is not displayed. The manipulator can be forced to display by clicking the middle mouse button anywhere in the same window.
The Alpha Gain Slider in the attribute editor for an image plane does not alter the transparency of the image plane, or the alpha gain is displayed incorrectly
The outline of the Paint Effects brushes or artisan brushes (e.g. sculpt) may remain on screen on the completion of a stroke, or may not be drawn at all, or may draw incorrectly.
Refresh of scenes containing Paint Effects can be very slow, or may ‘flash’ during redraw.
Hardware shadows cannot be displayed (Lighting->Shadows in pane menus)
You may additionally encounter the following on Panther systems (10.3):
16 bit sound files do not load into the timeline and will not playback
Information displayed in the command feedback area is unreadable as it is offset from the display area
Hardware lighting does not work while lights are moved via manipulators. When you release the mouse lighting is restored. (I think I understand what this means)
Line smoothing does not work in the hardware render buffer
Can someone explain what all this means to me, on my end? There is a lot of techno-speak there. On the pc, you don’t see any of these issues. I’ve considered buying a pc and then selling it at the end of the semester.
That brings up the next part of the question. Does anyone know of a site that compares render times between the mac and the pc for maya?
I hope that there are some people here that are knowledgable about this.
It sounds like you could get a better display card and avoid these issues. However in general I would say the PC is better if for no other reason than it has been supported longer than the mac. Your mac is not especially top of the line these days so if you are concerned about rendering times then you should get a new system anyway and you might as get a PC because your dollar will go farther. If you can afford it you should consider and opteron system it will kick ass and cost less than a top of the line mac if you build it yourself.
From the looks of it, on the maya site, all of the mac video cards that they recommend do not work with hardware rendering, even in the g5 macs. If I understand correctly, you definitely want hardware rendering because it is faster. Is that correct? I know that my current machine is the fastest, but I’m okay with that, but I do want everything to work and work correctly.
I’m just trying to decide a direction to go in. Outside of 3d, I wouldn’t really have any use for a pc, so there is a part of me that doesn’t want to go that way, but I’m not going to be buying a g5 anytime soon, so if that really is the better way to go, then that is what I will end up doing.
The hardware renderer has it’s uses but it is not a replacement for the software renderer or mental ray. Pretty much any display card can utilize the hardware renderer but certain features like shadows etc wll not work or work well. This is mainly an issue if you really need those features while working in the GUI.. which IMO you don’t need. They are nice but they are not essential. In most cases you will nto be doing final renders in the hardware renderer and besides rendering particles it’s mostly fast for things like broadcast design.
The issues I would be concerned about on the mac are the following problems:
You may encounter the following on Jaguar systems (10.2.x):
The texture placement manipulator is not displayed. The manipulator can be forced to display by clicking the middle mouse button anywhere in the same window.
The Alpha Gain Slider in the attribute editor for an image plane does not alter the transparency of the image plane, or the alpha gain is displayed incorrectly
The outline of the Paint Effects brushes or artisan brushes (e.g. sculpt) may remain on screen on the completion of a stroke, or may not be drawn at all, or may draw incorrectly.
Refresh of scenes containing Paint Effects can be very slow, or may ‘flash’ during redraw.
Information displayed in the command feedback area is unreadable as it is offset from the display area
The above are OS issues so if you upgrade then maybe it’s not a problem.
Lastly most places use PC’s so get used to the idea that you will most likely not be using a Mac to do 3d with Maya.
I’m looking at Maya 6 on OS X 10.3.5 and there are no problems with texture placement manipulators, nor are there any problems with the command feedback area. The paint effects brush issue does sometimes occur but it’s a minor annoyance and I think it’s probably due to the lack of support for hardware overlay in the graphics card.
If you do not want to own a pc after your semester is finished, don’t buy one. Selling it later will result in a losing investment.
The problem is that you can save alot of money building your own PC from the gorund up and you can’t do that with a Mac.
For $3 k I could build a kickass Opteron system with a workstation nvidia card and 2GBs of ram.
I think perhaps they have narrowed the price gap but I would prefer a platform that is more customizeable. The downside is that you are more likely to fry something or get a DOA part with a PC.. in eitehr case you pay a premium to get a preconfigured highend system.
just built one for 3000 euros… and yes the mac my friend has bought a month later for about the same price pales in comparason, in 3d (everything in the pc is faster in realworld tests). But maybe he just wanted the mac environ to work on. Me on the otherhand dont care what system im on as long is i get things done.
Thanks everyone for the feedback. I think I have made my decision.
I have found a Dell Precision 360 P4 2.8 GHZ w/ 800 mhz FSB, 1 Gig of ram, 80 gig hard drive, nvidia fx500 video card with a dvdrw, win xp pro and 3 years of next day warranty that I can get for $820 shipped. I think this is a good deal, am I wrong?
Last night, I was talking with a guy that does a lot of 3d stuff and he said to go for an athlon 64 or opteron. If I pieced one together, I could probably build one for around a grand, but I don’t know if the performance difference at that price point would be significant. Any thoughts?
Not worth consideration! its basicaly a lowend gamer card with full chip workings. Its evenen better to invest in gamer card tahn considering a 500, sure there are gliches but ist still better to have performance than something that costs money and doesnet realy offer anything in return.
The thing is, I don’t really know that I want to spend $600+ on a video card right now, since I’m new to Maya and everything. So in your opinion, what would be a better option than the fx500? Thanks for the feedback.
I wont recomend gamer cards to anyone, altough getting atop of the line gamer card will probably do fine for you.
The pint is if your not willing to spend the mneoy for a fx 1100 tehn your not willing to spend the money for a fx 500 either. Ist like throwing your money away, wich makes you even forther waya form a 1100.
I understand your point, and it makes perfect sense, but here’s my dilemma. I can’t buy a pc with the 1100 card for what I can get the one with the fx500 ($820). I guess my thought was to get this machine and then save up for a good card, say at the end of the year.
If I was only spending 3 or 400 on the machine, then I would probably go for it right now. I am trying to stay under $1000 with this purchase though.
get a 300 dollar FX card , save the cash towards an 1100.
As a beginner I won’t think you’d go too wrong with a 5700 or a 6800. Sure, its not an approved pro card but take the money saved and put it towards an 1100 later. Unless you plan on diving into particles pretty heavy or realtime content creation.
I could be wrong but thats my idea.
its fine… sure it might not be the fastest but its sweet as really
actually having not the fastest graphics card is a good way of making sure you dont make your models too dense
but yeah i work with it every day.. its fine and you’re not going to explode if you buy it.
but yeah you’re just starting out so i would use a gaming card… that will also be fine.. and good for games too… (the fx500 is not so hot on games.. the fx2000 is really good though)