Maya 8 Vs Maya Ple

I am a student at my local technical college and we have just started to learn Maya 8 as the main software of our Computer Animation program.

I have noticed that I cannot pull Maya 8 files into the Maya Personal Learning Edition that came with our textbook. Nor can I take files from PLE and open them in Maya 8 on the computers at school.

My question is, is there a way to get around this? I have done some great work at school on 8 and would like the chance to work on it more at home, and vice-versa.

Also, is it possible to bring Bryce and Poser files into Maya 8?

Forget Bryce and poser. I believe many new guys look up to these two, but you cant make anything good using them, even if you would, it would be worthless because you don't really put much work into it. Besides you can easily identify if the object is made with poser or not just by looking at it.And there is no point using bryce because maya has every single function of it.Anyhow i used these some time ago as well. As far as i can remember Bryce does not allow to export most of its objects at all, some however can be exported using obj, and poser i think also supports obj export. Good luck

P.S hmm maybe poser does not support obj, in that case you can use this thing called DAZ|studio to import poser and then export to obj from there.

QUOTE(martinh65 @ 05/13/07, 12:42 AM) [snapback]266041[/snapback]
My question is, is there a way to get around this? I have done some great work at school on 8 and would like the chance to work on it more at home, and vice-versa.

No thetas the entire point of PLE. Its so you can practice but cant use it for working. If you could sawp files freely what would stop people form using ple for work. In fact you cannot bring anything out of PLE.

Now even if you COULD take the model out of ple and use them in your school computers (and incidentally you can, it just requires a bit of in depth Maya knowledge), you'd be in full contract breech, which would bee as illegal as having a illegal copy of maya.

Anyway when you buy maya you can ask for a one time only service form autodesk to convert your ple models to the real deal.

But i do however believe they have actually lifted the opening of non ple files in plle tough just download the newest version of PLE form autodesks homepage.

QUOTE(thirt33n @ 05/13/07, 07:10 PM) [snapback]266047[/snapback]
Forget Bryce and poser. I believe many new guys look up to these two, but you cant make anything good using them, even if you would, it would be worthless because you don't really put much work into it. Besides you can easily identify if the object is made with poser or not just by looking at it.
P.S hmm maybe poser does not support obj, in that case you can use this thing called DAZ|studio to import poser and then export to obj from there.

Please excuse this newbie - I'm really trying to get my head around the thrust of this forum. I'm not sure I follow your statements. I'll be the first to admit that I'm not a professional 3D artist or designer or architect, but I am interested in the medium, and see tremendous potential. I have been able to "create" 3D "objects" in Blender (saved in .blend format) which I subsequently exported to Wavefront .obj format. I was able to import those Wavefront .obj files into Poser 6 and 7. So, it is doable.

What is the basis for your objections to these programs? I'm a Poser user - there is a huge Poser user base, and thought that Maya might be a good medium for creating content for Poser 'characters'. However, from what I've been able to ascertain, Maya 8.5 ple is merely a "get-to-know-the-software" trial version with no means of importing or exporting files. Is that correct?

Another member Joojaa said something along the lines of:
QUOTE
No thetas the entire point of PLE. Its so you can practice but cant use it for working. If you could sawp files freely what would stop people form using ple for work. In fact you cannot bring anything out of PLE.

By 'working' I'm going to assume that this individual meant that nothing can be saved out of ple.

Makes Maya rather useless for the casual user...

The idea of doing 3d is that you can get whatever you want out of stuff. 3d is more than just having the ability of using polygonal data. In fact i cant remember the last time is used pure polygons for anything in maya.

The core of the issue is the graph, 3d is about graphs of things. And those graphs rarely, if ever export form a app to another.

Poser is basically toy its designed for people who draw stuff on screen and its evolved to a singelton rig over the ages. Its a quite ok rig tho but quite recognizable and has no resell value.

However 3d splits into several niches poser carters only illustration for very lowest end quality of them mainly and roughly the categories are:

Rendered Stills:

Technical visualisation
Architectural visualisation
Illustration

Data:

Technical design
Industrial design
Architectural design
Technical manufacture
Games asset
Medical visualisation

Rendered Animations:

Movie industry
Tv industry

poser is a simple tool, but its not truly yours in firtsplace so theres only limitted sales market for those things (aside of what the 3d magazines tell you, its a ruse to keep yu buying them there only ever jobs for 10% of the best people in any area)

It cant attack full fledged multi user production where you are the final say so what is done where and when. Doing a movie in poser would take ages.

PS: being able to manipulate polygons is easy, just like pixels you can manage without photo shop. But in the range of 3d id put being able to do the right polygons as 0.1% of the picture. Just like doing image manipulations is just 75% of photo shops tool set and price 25% being the best printer facility in the market. (which is a BIG deal, on the average a photoshop user that does commercial print work can save 15% of their print costs and for a agency that can translate to yearly savings of 10,000$ per artist!)

Likewise mayas a custom pipeline custom rig custom geometry tool for firms such as pixar that need to push the envelope into something that hasn't been used yet.

Didn't read joojaas reply here....it's loong....

QUOTE
I'll be the first to admit that I'm not a professional 3D artist or designer or architect, but I am interested in the medium, and see tremendous potential

So am I and likely another 50% of this forums users. Joojaa is way out there as her profile status says, so you should probobly always strongly consider what she says because she has the experience of everyone else on this forum combined...from what i'v seen. Then there are some other experienced users. And there are The Professionals- the ones that actually make a living out of this, which is not supposed to mean that they are more experience then some hobbyist...although it usually is the case.

QUOTE
I have been able to "create" 3D "objects" in Blender (saved in .blend format) which I subsequently exported to Wavefront .obj format. I was able to import those Wavefront .obj files into Poser 6 and 7. So, it is doable.

My expression "you cant make anything using poser and bryce" is not to be taken literally...I'll try to explain below.

QUOTE
What is the basis for your objections to these programs?

Poser...I'm not telling that it's bad...by no means. I'm telling that it's on a whole different level. The good thing about it is that it's simple so it's a good place for new users to start exploring CGI(3d) world.

What did i mean by "you cant make anything"? You probobly can, but typically poser users don't do that. You buy something that someone else made, and all you do is move it into places using some simple UI buttons. Maybe adjust it little bit, and then render (without getting into the more advance techniques). Therefore you don't create any artworks. What matters is not the result but the effort. I'd be more impressed to see a C++ programmed Cube revolving on the screen (which would take a good 500 or so lines of code), then the pre-made 101273..whatever polycount model rendered in poser. Of course the one person who should get the credit is the artist at E-frontier who actually modeled and even rigged it so fantastically. Once again. This is a great software for the right users, i know because i used it too, and many did, or do...I believe.

QUOTE
Maya 8.5 ple is merely a "get-to-know-the-software" trial version with no means of importing or exporting files. Is that correct?

PLE stands for Personal Learning Edition, so yes, its a trial version to test it out and see if you like it.

QUOTE
Another member Joojaa said something along the lines of:
QUOTE
No thetas the entire point of PLE. Its so you can practice but cant use it for working. If you could sawp files freely what would stop people form using ple for work. In fact you cannot bring anything out of PLE.

By 'working' I'm going to assume that this individual meant that nothing can be saved out of ple.

Yes, because Quote:If you could sawp files freely what would stop people form using ple for work, therefore nobody or less users would buy the software.

QUOTE
Makes Maya rather useless for the casual user...

Yes and no...In the first place is the price...a casual user has to really cut his expenses to be able to afford maya in most cases. Yes, when you get maya it's useless because you can't do anything with it, but you then have this huge opportunity to improve endlessly... At first it looks as if maya's slowing you down and nothing works the way it's supposed to work, and it's playing tricks on you and has so many buttons that you will never use know them all etc... Over time you get used to it and it gets better and better until it becomes second nature. So in the end..if you are serious about getting into 3d at the moment maya actually is your best bet (except the price again).