Sorry if this question has already been posted before, but does anyone still model with Maya's NURBS? and if so, what and why? The reason I ask is that I almost never see anyone post a model, organic or not, modeled in NURBS these days. Its all polygons and SubD's. Almost every character model I've seen these days are subd's and in fact, alot of the cars I'm seeing modeled these days are also. In fact any organic/industrial object that requres smooth curves seems to be subds. Hard edge objects are polygons. The only nurbs models I see these days are hard objects coming out of Rhino (it seems that Rhino's tools are better implemented than in maya?)
So does anyone still bother with Maya's nurbs? I still see some books that want to cover nurbs modeling and yet it seems so out of style (and painstaking too) that it seems like a relic of the past.
I think it's quite common that people still model in nurbs, they just convert their object to polys or Subd's. Quickly get the shape down in nurbs in a matter of time etc.
I can't speak for others, but I think w/ the increase in poly tools and subd's, people like to have their final ouput in those.
Many facilites do still model in NURBS because of the inherit UV's that come along with them. They then use a conversion process to preserv those when converting to Sub-D's or Polys for final output. NURBS afford you the ulitmate in control which for many pruposes may be too much or more than you need. Industrial Designers will continue to use NURBS for the control.
Nurbs offer an unparalelled amount of controll.. and unless subdivs can get major enhancements increse in computer speed will more or less bring nurbs back in the game when the power is enough to properly hanle trims in real time too... (eingeneering apps do this kind of deformation with huge precicions so i dont se why not... but not realy in real time, yet!)
Also Nurbs are a wonderful tool to make those subd surfaces. Since it offers you a way to rebuild areas without needing to worry about things. Also patching makes for very good edge loops.
it seems to me that nurbs tools are here to stay... only the ignorant ignore them. (quite many do because its realy too much over their head, but knowing this can make the diference between securing a job versus no job)
Ok well the Aye's have it its true, poly modeling can be p fairly intuitive which lends itself to subd's. My biggest complaint about poly's is that you're stuck with the LOD that you built it with, which has partially inspired me to work with nurbs. It just doesn't seem that popular, so I wasn't sire if was perceived as a waste of energy these days. I've always wanted to work more with nurbs but it seems that alot of tutorials really don't go into depth about using the surfacing tools for things other than character models. In fact, alot of the tuts I've seen always start with things like 'create a sphere, now lets scale and stretch.....' or they make objects out of simple primitives and lathe operations which is really not where I want to go with it (granted that techniques might work well for some things). Rhino seemed to be used more for industrial objects but I assumed that nurbs are nurbs and the tools used too work with them would be essentially the same across apps. Is this not the case?
So can anyone point me in the direction of good tuts or other materials relating to modeling in NURBS? thanks for the comments folks
Well i wouldnt say its awste of time just take a look at the subd modells steven stahlberg does... I think he uses paches a s a base for his subd models!