HI all.
I have looked through the past post but I would like to hear from anyone who has some experience with both an Octane and Win 2K.
I am used to working on a Dual R10000-250 Octane ESI and now migrating to a Dual Athalon System. The rendering speed of the Dual Athalon system will be much improved, but I am concearned with Graphics. The choice for graphics card is between Fire GL2 and Geforce 3.
I haven’t used maya on Win2K before, will I be compleatly disapointed in the graphics performance of the GL2 or Gefoce 3? I will be using the machine for 2 and 3D like, Maya, Mtor, Photoshop, Premier, Aftereffects etc.
Dont think so..
Just by taking a glimpse at any 3d test you will see that u are to be the happiest man on earth the first day.
The SI line of graphics is no god at all compared to modern pc 3d cards, dont know about the artisan stuff cause I dont use it, but I do know that since I tried a geforce 256 DDR card on my PC I left my R10k dual octane SI to do SETI crunching and began running all the simulation/3d stuff on on the PC.
The Geforce even beats the Onyx IR cards (if u dont use multiple pipes for one display but thats a tab costly).
I work on a 300mhz R12K ESI box with houdini, amazon, maya, EI and a few other misc apps.
I picked up a 1100mhz athlon during christmas and it pretty much smokes an octane with a geforce2mx board [90$-ish] in everything BUT AA wireframes, and possibly toying with alpha gain in imageplane settings in maya. But those seem to be driver issues then hardware. In terms of drawing polygons and fillrate a low end pc card can smoke an esi based octane.
That being said if you got the money, and you are not concerned that much about maximum game performance get either a Quadro DCC [aka quadro “3” based on geforce3], Firegl 2 or 4 or a wildcat II.
If the only 3d application you use is maya… then a geforce would be fine and would be a nice money saver. An issue for the last few years was that alot of the pc cards didn’t do 100% of the opengl for maya in hardware [image planes/overlays] so using tools like paintfx/artisan would be slow. Some drivers elminitated most of those issues but the odd one still pops up. Maya 4 however, has removed most of these drawing operations to make it more friendly and faster with lower end video cards. So I’m not sure if theres going to be much of a need for wildcat II/Firegl for maya 4.. that remains to be seen yet.
Either way.. make sure you get a store with good support. don’t go for the cheapest retailer.. you’d want a place that would have no problems replacing a bad motherboard on the fly .