Motion Trail Affect Anim Curve?

I was playing around recently with the motion trail feature in Maya (Animate > Create Motion Trail), and noticed that as you manipulate the keyframes in the graph editor, the position of the points on the motion trail updated in real time. So, there must be some means by which those elements are connected.

I was wondering if its possible to reverse the influence...meaning, can you make it so that if you select a point/locator/etc. of the motion trail (which is an issue in and of itself) and manipulate it in the viewport, could that update the keyframes in the graph editor?

Any thoughts?

QUOTE
So, there must be some means by which those elements are connected.

They connect out to the transformation node. Once it is marked dirty the trail will re sample the curve. Its not connected to the anim curves per see as maya cares nothing if you drive the values via expression for instance. So you might have a situation where one of the channels is NOT keyed buts ist still works out fine.

QUOTE
I was wondering if its possible to reverse the influence...

Yes but not with mel not atleast practically. However the point is that if you wished to have a path that affected your motion the normal maya way would be either to:

  • Use path anim, you can allways convert that to keyframes if you need to or keyframes to anim curves if you care to.
  • Create a new class of nodes work like tcb curve wich is quite easi to form into both representations.

The idea is that this is a hard nut to crack. Because maya does NOT limit you to 3 curves that must be connected and keyed in unison. But yes its possible to do.

Not practical tough. because the interpolation would be a bit wierd to say the least.

Somebody has allready done soem eowrk towards theis search the repository.

Thanks Joojaa...I'll start looking around.

My whole idea for a neat tool, would be to create or import some animation, have that generate a motion trail or some kind of curve, with cv's every so many frames, then be able to manipulate the cv's and have it affect the motion on the object. Any initial ideas on how this could possibly be done?

Use path anim.

This is a deep philosophical statement. It goes deep into what we do when we keyframe.

If i was very anally interested in the shape of the Trail, i would be drawing the trail and pacing timing in that ergo. Path anim.

If on the other hand im interested in doing keyframe work in the graph editor i would not need to know the shape of the motion trail because im interested in the motion derivates of the things and thus the indiudal tangent directions are of concern to me.

They represent a sort of mutually exclusive data in my mind. So wwhet you have here is a tool that is COOL but serves no greater purpose on teh grand scheme on how most peopel animate.

I mean Max has this in forms of tcb splines, and i never ever see anybody really using it like that. But see theres a problem with tcb splines they suck i mean i choose path anim any day over it, even if path anim sucks too it just sucks less.