My mantis thingy

hi i just started work on this guy a lil while ago and i haven’t really touched him in a few weeks. there’s still a lot of work to be done on him and i just wanted a few critiques if that’s ok

There is much to be done on this model… I don’t mean to be harsh, but it looks as though there is nothing solid about this “thingy”. - Like there are no bones under the skin… It seems like one of those rubbery bendy toys that have a wire running through it so you can bend it into poses. And that is probably going to give you fits once you try to rig this beasty for animation. (i.e. look at the shoulders, arms and wrists - and KNEES)

The mouth part makes little sense to me.

Everything looks as though you’ve made it outta clay… It seems rather free-form thought too. Like you designed it as you made it, thinking - “Dude, wings!.. Wings would be cool… And little spikey things on the back.” Etc, etc.

Wow… That was kinda harsh… I apologize… It is an ambitious model, but the execution of it needs work. I can relate to it in some ways because it reminds me of my first attempts in modeling.

No worries, my friend… The key thing is to keep practicing and improving.

i don’t mind criticism but maybe you could give me some suggestions as to how i can improve it. it is the main reason i posted it. it is a pretty free form model. remember it’s an insect mainly… insects don’t have skeletons.

If it is an insect, work on making it a bit more like an insect. Right now, it could be a demon-scorpion-bat-thing. Right, insects don’t have bones, so emphasize this if its the look you want. Work on the look of an exoskeleton…the rigid body. Yours look very soft, clay-like and fleshy. I can see bones and knees a bit in the limbs…this doesn’t make me think insect at all. AND..the wings. No insect I have ever seen has wings like this. These are more avian or reptilian. Dragon-like.
Look at the praying mantis…it has more than the 4 legs. It has different wings, it has different segmentation in it’s body. Think how this guy will move..not just the wings, but how he will look up, turn, contort..etc.

-Dirty

Well… Like Dirty said. Make it more insect-like. And Insects DO have skeletons - exoskeletons. (Which would make your rigging much easier)

Hmmm… Suggestions then… Yes. Lemme see…

Make it generally more insect-like.

  • straighten out the limbs and body and make them segmented. - i.e. a straight, rigid shoulder segment connected to a straight, rigid bicep connected to a straight, rigid forearm etc, etc, etc… The whole thing should be comprised of a bunch of pieces - armour, if you will… For instance. Every finger joint is a piece that doesn’t really deform, but it has a joint underneath the armour that does.
  • Lose the bat-like wings… Give it dragonfly wings or something. It would seem more correct and look SO much cooler with translucent wings - even though the creature IS complete fantasy.
  • Personally, I would get rid of the scorpion tail too… I dunno what I’d really replace it with - but that’s my opinion.
  • And the more I look at the mouth, the more I dislike it… Here again, make them more mandible-like.

And, just in case I haven’t beat the dead horse enough… Make it more buggy… Like Dirty suggested - find some insect pics, and choose parts of insects that you like, and emulate that.

Is that more helpful?.. I understand that I’m pretty much asking you to totally remake your model. But, in the end, you (and others) willl like it much better.

alright cool… i’ve got this guy on hold for now but i’ll try to re-work him. i’ll put an updated pic up soon hopefully. thanks for the suggestions.