Need a critique please

Heres a shot of my latest model. Im not the best at lighting so if you have any tips please let me know. Dont mind the landscape, its just a basic test. Think i need less ambient light? maybe darker shadows? I think Ive been looking at it too long.

Yeah, I think you need darker shadows. What kind of feel are you looking for? This looks very “video gamey” (lighting/environment, not the model). I would go with less ambient and more spots, but I’m no lighting expert. Your textures/model is excellent! My only suggestion there is maybe go with a darker hose coming from the back tanks. I would think it would be a black rubber hose. This one looks white/gray. Just to see what it would look like, try just playing with the gamma level in photoshop. This way, you can get a quick idea/something to shoot for.

I’m just guessing here, but I am pretty sure he is trying to enter this model into the cgchannel contest as it matches the them/rules perfectly (right?)
Anyway, nice model. The texturing needs a lot more work, imho. But not just on the model, but the landscape is horrible. More texturing is needed there, and the hills in the back should not look like triangled polygons.
But it’s a realy nice start.

model looks good…

only thing i can see wrong is you have a light shining on the back inside tire which makes it appear funny

also..just being picky…on an off road vehicle..u should have the air filter/intake piped so its above everything else..kinda like the safari and aussie vehicles…do a search on safari vehicles to get what i mean

Yeah, the shadows should be darker, and also sharper. When you’re out in the bright sun, like in the desert, shadows are pretty strong.

Ok i took a harder look at the image again. And here are some things:

The front, not sure if that is a strange bumper, or a bucket for plowing, but it should have a lot of dirt stuck to it. Also it’s missing oxidation, add a lot of red and orange in places where you expect rain to spend most of it’s half life running and pooling around.
The treads should have a bit of sand around them, as they were just driven miles through sand. Also don’t the sides of tires all have some kind of labeling?
Another point, on the weels, a lot of the metal texturing is too homogenious, as well as other places on your vehicle. You need to add more contrast.
I can understand that some guns look much newer than the rest of the car parts (if they were just placed on the vehicle) but technicaly they should be full of dirt. ESPECIALY with no rims on the wheels, anything near them, (or side of the car for that matter) would get sandblasted beyond hell. (I feel sorry for the driver when ever he turns left or right!) Should add some nicks and a lot of dirt/sand particles all over. Especialy on the tarp where sand would be expected to pool in minute quantities.
Watch out for the one gun on the side, it’s barrel would be cloged in real life. Put a plug on it so you dont blow yourself up when you shoot that thing?
Also, where is the seat for the driver? There seem to be no internal devices for a driver that I can readily see. A side-mirror may also be needed.
BTW, I hope he dont dive that thing in town, as most of the vision through the front appears to be blocked. Also I hope it’s a midget who drives, ESPEICALY since now i realize there are supposed to be two occupants that squeeze into that thing. One for the gun on top right?
The over-all colors tend to be a little poor for my tastes, but maybe it’s a personal thing. If you save in a different format than gif, it may improve. I try to avoid gif’s like the plague.

update above…

Wow, i certainly didnt expect so many replies! lol. Thx for all the comments and honest criticism. The deadline was this Friday so what you see above ( updated on friday ) is what I sent in for the challenge. I wish i came back here before friday, I totally forgot to check back! (lack of sleep, and im new here). Please keep in mind, this was an entry for the VEHICLE challenge and not the landscape contest. I know the desert setting is pathetic, i was only concerned with the Vehicle itself. Im going to continue to work on it and hopefully animate it for my next reel. Thanks for the great feedback! I’ll work on it.

previous shot: http://www.cydonian.com/server/wip/PA_vehicle_sigma9b.gifhttp://www.cydonian.com/server/wip/PA\_vehicle\_sigma9b.gif

very nice.

Well do keep us informed. I kind of liked your vehicle. I’d like to see the demo-reel asp.