Need a professional crit

Rip my work apart if you have to. I’ll tell you that I seem to always have a bit of trouble with the ears and everything. This model was hard cause I tried to model myself. It’s not the easiest thing in the world. Ok. here is the link to the pic.

http://www.jenisoncorp.com/zack/wpgraphics/models/Zack.htm

I also have a question. I have been making head for a while now. I have made them in nurb patches and polygons. I want to make sure I have been creating then right. I want them to be able to animate easy. I thikn that the polygon heads are fine but my nurb patches always seem a little bit askew. I get seems and I just can’t seem to figure out how to get rid of them. I think what happens is that I have setup the patches wrong. Maybe you can give me some advice on them. I have my models online which you can download if you need to. Also I have the wire frame of one of my patch heads in the image. Just go to:

http://.jenisoncorp.com/zack

then go to “3d” then to “models” and you’ll see that the two patch heads I have made are the only heads with textures. Thanks for any help you can give and any crit you can give on the above head.

Cyphre

PS: If you call me ugly I’m going to whoop some @$$

Edited by admin on 01/12/01 06:57:24 PM.

OK, great start the overall shape is there, however the head does need some work. Firstly the lighting is dull and does not show off your model. Try to get some more contrast in the images especially hightlights (not specular) to really bring out the 3d shape. 3 point lighting - main source 100 % back light 50 % and fill 15%.

Now the geometry, check your eye ball size (should only be the size of a ping pong ball) the iris shape looks a little large. The shape of the eyes look wrong, make sure the inner coners are lower than the outer. Bridge of the nose needs some work, see if you can get rid of that strange dimple between the eyes - smooth it out. Nasal wings look to flat and need some rounding out at the join. And the lips… be especially careful with the bottom lip, the lower crease rarely follows the lip edge. At the edges of the bottom lip there is hardly any crease at all. Really look at your reference material and model what you can definately see, don’t let your imagination fill in the gaps!
More can be told in the wireframe, sometimes the way the face is built can be limiting. If it’s sub d’s post the wire frame and I can tell you more. Good start don’t give up just keep working at it!

Oh yeah and buy “The Artists Complete Guide to Facial Expression” by Gary Faigin, the one and only text book on the face.

cheers
Andrew

Looks kind of Vampireish

Eric

I agree, nice start for your first model.

First off, it looks like you’ve used a sphere to create the characters head, for a start I wouldn’t recommend that technique, as you get weird geometry usually in the top
and bottom of the sphere, Instead, if you like to model with this technique, use a box instead, and use Maya’s smooth operation to smooth it a couple of times, you get a much nicer model at the end of it I promise you. I also noticed that you can clearly see the contours of the original sphere you used, you must have a lot of tightly packed polys near these edges for them to be defined the way they are.

It’s probably best if you model to the least amount of polys as possible and then either convert to subd’s or smooth later, that way your not spending ages modelling and you become a lot more productive, you’ll be surprised at just how detailed a low-poly mesh can become when it is converted to subds or smoothed.

I don’t know if your working from a photograph on your desk or as an ImagePlane, but if not I would recommedn you do, and also get someone to take a photo of yourself from a side angle too and map that into, well, the side plane, this will help enormously, as if your just working from a front view, your face will probably end up looking quite flat, unless you have that side view to know what sort of perspective your working to.

Right, other things, the nose is too sharply pointed towards the front and seems to be pulled in too much near the middle.
The area above the lip joining to the nose seems excessively wide and at the same time spoils the appearance of the lips and makes them look really stretched too.

I have to admit though, I would also need to see a wireframe to give you more advice. Biggest thing is your ears though, I’d concentrate on that area too, here’s a brief polygonal tutorial on creating ears I found on the net, it’s lightwave related but that doesn’t matter becuase all the techniques can be applied within Maya.

http://earth.vol.com/~natzke/ear.htm

Regards

Ok, I changed a few things on it. I tried to fix everything you guys said. Here’s the new image. It also has the low and the high poly mesh next to it.

http://www.jenisoncorp.com/zack/wpgraphics…odels/Zack2.htm

Yes I did model it from a poly. I didn’t think it was that noticable but when you said something I went and changed it. I just erased his head and rebuilt it. I will have to start foma poly cube next time. These are great crits. Everything you see wrong with it just tell me. Even if the whole thing is build wrong just let me know. If I am not told I’ll keep modeling them the same way.

Thanks again for all the good crits so far.
Cyphre

An alternate method for starting your head would be to use the sphere but rotate it so that the two poles of the sphere are in the horizontal plane and located approximately at the location of the ears. Next get rid of the tri-polys that make the poles and then rebuild a single poly plane on either side with the remaining points that were left from removing the tri polys. These polys can now be extruded to build your ear geometry.

ooh, triangles, bad, bad triangles. 8)

For smoothing purposes avoid modelling with triangles at all costs, this may seem hard at first but it isn’t really once you get the hang of it, and if you really can’t you can usually hide triangles in areas that aren’t seen. Notice the messy final high-res mesh where the triangles were.

Overall the mesh seems badly put together in general, you’d probably run into loads of problems when it comes to animate this character, the box modelling method is one of the nicest ways to model and you will get a really nice smooth model out of it once your finished. I’m currentlu updating my website, and I’m going to put up some Maya related tutorials, one of which will be creating a head in subds’, but that’s no good to you atm, I can send you a very basic low-poly head to look at if you want, that way you look at it and learn (please note:- this is just for you, so nobody else email me and ask me for a copy (you’ll see it when the tut goes up)).
If you do ask me for it, once you get it smooth it or convert to subd’s and watch the difference, notice the layout for animation and smooth curves all running into each other.

You need more curvature to your model, he seems too boxy from all angles. Anyways, send me a private mail with your email addy and I’ll send you that head, you’ll probably learn loads from that alone, as I simply can’t go into everything within here.

Regards

I’d have to agree with James that your mesh is a mess. I come from a Lightwave background where you don’t have the freedom to slap polys together in any such matter. Even with the freedom that Maya provides always try to stick with quad polys where ever possible, this is true for Max also. This is so you don’t get unexpected bumps. Nurbs work so well because they are a grid of squares. Best bet is to model in circles like you have with the eyes. Do that for the mouth.

see http://www.samurice.com/andrew/face.jpg
for a face I am working on at the moment, this is in Lightwave, but the same rules apply in Maya. This is not the cleanest meshes and perhaps the detail is a little overkill but see how the lines flow together. As for box modeling method, I prefer to work on the parts (eyes, nose mouth) and then join them together. Hope this helps!

good luck
Andrew

read this stuff. its focused on mirai but you can use just about 90% of the material and apply it to your model.
http://maxrovat.sns.hu/subdiv/
hope this helps

-M-K-

http://homepages.go.com/~ambient\_whisper/intro.html

hi,

i’m a student hence my question: what exactly is “box modelling” , any tutorials?

what’s your favorite? Nurbs or polygons for modelling a head? Why?