New fast machine opinion

Hey all,
Im moving overseas soon and have been thinking of building a new hot machine to keep me satisfied for awhile with XSI ( specially with v2 on its way.
Tell me what you all think whether from experience or expertise.

Dual p4 xeon 1.7
supermico motherboard P4DC6
rdram that i can afford 512 to start
this is my main interest as a workhorse for 3d work. Unfortunatly it leaves me a little short for an emmdiate highend video card. I am thinking of putting a gforce3 into it until I can afford a wildcat or simular. Please let me know known issues or problems you all have experienced or would forsee.

Thanks as usual =o)
RaiThioS

How much are those Xeons gonna cost you?

I’d recommend a Dual Athlon 1.4GHz with the new cheaper Tyan Tiger MP, or the more expensive Tyan Thunder K7 if you want SCSI and stuff integrated (and an AGP Pro slot). Combine that with some PC2100 SDRAM, and a nice graphics card, and you’re all set, and blazing much faster than on those Xeons.

Ive heard from many people who sell/used tyan that they are junk. Specially for running dual. Yea i know the xeons are spendy but they are stable and they are workhorses. Anyone else see XSI running on that HP at the soft party? WOW

Thanks for your reply but im not ready to try the potato chips yet =o))

Raithios

I’ve used Tyan boards before, and been very happy with them, but I’ve never tried any of their dual boards so I dunno…

The reviews seem to like the Tyan dual socket A boards, and I am getting one of those myself, but until then I can’t really say anything but read the reviews, and decide from what you know. Maybe there are some glitches, but the Thunder K7 was developed to be a server board and Tyan spent a lot of time making that board rock-solid. So from what I hear/read I recommend it, but only as far as my sources are trustworthy

I have dual athalons running XSI and have not had ANY problems, buying xeons is just wasting money for a slower chip!

Xeons won’t be slower for much longer! When they pass 2.0 GHz…fairly soon…they’ll creep back ahead of the Athlons. The two things that have held P4’s back are lack of dual processor support and RDRAM which has lower burst than DDR used by Athlons. With the new 2.0 GHz P4’s, they now support dual processors (a few tweaks still needed), and also take advantage of DDR memory.

Another thing to consider is the bus speed. Athlons run at 266MHz, Xeons run at 400MHz.

Matt


Matt Lind
Animator / Technical Director
Softimage certified instructor:
Softimage|3D
Softimage|XSI
speye_21@hotmail.com

Get the new Quadro DCC chip. Xeons are a huge waste of money.

I agree, Xeon are a waste of money. Just wait till Dual athlon chip move to HT with Dual channel 333mhz ddr chip =].

Everyone is screaming AMD !! lol . Now Im completley stuck between the two. I thought Toms hardware would help me decide since all the great hardware reviews and benchmark tests are to be trusted there… but Since I dont have a machine of each to test xsi and 3d apps on I still cant decide. Great things are said about each with advantages on both sides. I think intel has gotten a bad rap on the new p4 but according to toms hardware allot of it has to do with software not taking advantage of certain aspects of the chip itself.
The p4 1.7 xeons are 300 bucks a pop with 3 year warranty. Due to the recent price cuts it isnt that outrageous of a price anymore.
On the AMD side… What is there current fastest chip ( 4 dual)? Best motherboard combinations with ram etc.
I may be setting myself up for converting to potatoe chips but hey i want the best puter for the money =o)
Thanks again for the replys

RaiThioS

OK, I work with a reseller, so I’ve had the opportunity to run both a dual-P4/1.7-Xeon system and a dual-AMD/MP system. In all truth, they’re pretty much equivalent, with the AMD just slightly edging out the P4 on a few things. The system bus speeds are NOT comparable, like apples and oranges. The 400MHz Intel bus isn’t faster than the 266MHz AMD bus. Rambus RAM is technically, but not practically, faster than DDR RAM. Looks great on paper, but that’s it.

Things to keep in mind:

The AMD system is significantly cheaper to build at the moment.
Intel is supposedly going to dramatically chop the price of P4s in a bid to squash AMD.
Intel just released a 2GHz Xeon, soon to be in a dual config.
DDR SDRAM (for the AMD system) is stupid cheap. $160 for 1GB of premium-brand memory.
AMD is also due for a speed update very, very soon.

If you’re looking for interactivity whilst working in your 3D app, your graphics card and RAM matters more than your procs. Buy a GeForce3 and run SoftQuadro, buy a Quadro DCC, or buy a Wildcat.

If you want to render quickly and have fast compositing interaction, then worry about your procs.

Cheer on both companies, because when they fight, we (the consumer) benefit.

Have a nice day!

If you insist on getting Pentium 4s I would recommend at least waiting until the Northwood core is released. Until then I couldn’t recommend P4s for anything except Quake…

The advantage with the Athlon system is that it’s so cheap that even if you build it and if you don’t like it for some reason, you can just make it a render slave and buy another system with the leftover money

AMD vs. Intel,
Even if the two are identical in price and performance, there is still reason to buy AMD if it meets your needs. Don’t forget this won’t be the last box you buy. If AMD goes out of business, Intel won’t bother innovating anymore. We may all suffer for a long time if Intel is the only choice in town.

THE ONLY REASON THAT THE INTEL CPU’s ARE SO FAST AND CHEAP IS BECAUSE AMD EXSITS…PERIOD!!!

The second that AMD is out of the picture, you can kiss innovation and price good-bye. Intel is not trying to compete, they are trying to get rid of competition.

Urp

Its true…i remember seeing an intel long term roadmap and they were only going to be up to 500Mhz PIII-type chips by now.

I beleive AMD chips are currently technically superior.
If power concerns (UPS etc.) are a problem just think;

Current P4 systems needs a 460watt PSU, compared to an athlon MAX requirement of 350!

As for stability concerns, i dont beleive intel platforms are much better (anyone remember the i820 chipset?).

And if anyone recommends a p4 over an athlon at this current point in time, you know they’re an intel shareholder.