Quadro Fx 3500 Cards

Hi is there a difference between quadro FX 3500 cards with a parts number ES357AA and ones with a parts number 435681-B21?

I’ve tried looking up specs for each number but don’t get many thought the few I find are the same.

If you look at this link 3500 cards you’ll see that a quadro FX 3500 with parts number ES357AA is only about $450 while one with the parts number 435681-B21 is more then 3x as much at over $1300!

Any of the stores selling the 435681-B21 parts number one either list nothing or very little on it spec wise so thats no help in seein if there is any actual difference between the cards besides just the parts number.

doesn’t really matter you should always buy the newest quadros as the SECOND number denotes chip set (while first is just something that denotes price, but price doesnt reflect effect in the way consumer cards do) your in all essence buying a obsolete card for much money. The economics of quadros don’t work in a logical way so the price does not reflect the cards real power. (this is because quadros have long lifespan on the shelves even tough they are obsolete, mainly so that if you have a seruious factory application that requires a specific quadro you can get it. This ups quadro prices quite substantially)

I think you missed the point Joojaa that they are not different Quardos they are both Quardo FX 3500s (so the whole ignore first number it’s the second number thats important thing doesn’t matter as it’s not talking about different cards) and it is only the manufacture number from HP that is different and one is selling for about $450AU and the other (with a different number from HP) is selling for nearly $1400AU.

So if they are both Quadro FX 3500 cards then why is one selling for 3x the cost of the other when spec wise they seem to be the same except for the number from HP.

And it isn’t just a matter of some stores are selling it for $1400 and others are selling it for $450 as looking at the website it’s only the Quadro FX 3500 with a manufacture number of ES357AA that is selling for $450 there are none being sold for more then that and only the Qaudro FX 3500 with manufacture number 435681-B21 that is being sold for $1400 and no cheaper.

There is even one store that is selling both the ES357AA card and the 435681-B21 card at those vastly different prices. So if they are both identical Quadro FX 3500 cards except for the manufacture number then why is one prices 3x higher then the other?

1 is an OEM card. the other is a distribution products.

OEM card carries 1 yr (at least in USA), distribution is 3 yrs.

same chip. We are a distributor. I am surprised how much price delta is in Australia. here in USA, price difference is about 50%. OEM cards here is more than AU pricing. but our distributor pricing is only about 60% of AU pricing.

QUOTE
I think you missed the point Joojaa that they are not different Quardos they are both Quardo FX 3500s (so the whole ignore first number it’s the second number thats important thing doesn’t matter as it’s not talking about different cards)

No you missed my point. Theres no point in getting a quadro 3500 it represents a old chipset. So it doesnt matter what the 3500 costs it will be over proced nonetheless. Unless you have a application that only works on a 3500 that basically is a control item in factory or airplane so you dont need to redo testing protocols.

see the sequence of cards is as follows.

1500 3500 1700 3700 NOT:

1500 1700 3500 3700

See the thing is the series numbering in quadr cards dont represent the same kind of thing as consumer cards do.

so while

1500 and 3500 then the 3500 is better. However comparasion of 1700 and 3500 doesn’t yield the same thing. Granted the 3500 sends more pure old style opengl 1.0 tramngles but the pixel shader of the 1700 kicks the 3500 out the door.

So the ONLY truly valid choices for a 3d application user is the latest second number in series. Thet means thet the only cards WORTH any consideration outside a test needed environemmnt (wich does not apply to this board) are:

1700
3700
4600
5600

Because they are the latest chipsets. Rest are 3 year old technolgy at premium prices. Prices of qadro ranges DO not reflect newness, they reflect something totaly else. Since getting a card TESTED to work on mission critical platforms is Much more costly then just getting a old chip set.’

This is why a proce of a old chipset qudro doesn’t drop like a consumer card would. Because of this simple fact theres never any real idea in buying a older series of quadro card just to save some bucks since there is no super bargains to gain. I eman you wouldnt buy a consumer 7600 today either for 3d graphics instead youd buy a 8600 or 8800

Doesn’t the 3500 use the same GPU as the GeForce 8600? Not like it’s a 3 year old chip.

And it’s still a fast card (compared to using a gamer card) and no other Quadro around the same price performance near as good in any of the benchmarks so I don’t see why there’s no point getting one.

And whether or not there is a point in getting one that’s not what the orginal question was about just why there was such a big diff between the 2 same cards

Well okay its only 2 years old,

Anyway the reason is that the way 3d is being rasterized is changing, allready you see someprograms migrate and 3500 is landlocked. The benchmarks ive seen for maya does not reflect what happens once you turn high quality displays on in maya. And quite frankly its only when the scene is extremely heavy when you turn it of nowadays.

go directly to 3700 its not that much more expensive.

Remeber a dime saved on getting not exactly what you desire is not a dime saved ist a dime spent on wrong thing.

QUOTE
Doesn’t the 3500 use the same GPU as the GeForce 8600?

I dont tink so… the 600 and 700 range is G8x maybe even G9x series so a 1700 would be equal to 8600 or even 9600, after a bit of digging 3500 is based on a G71, so 3500 is a 7900. You will have to remeber the quadro series are a bit ahead of the game

Even if im wrong theres a another proof at least the 8600GT and GTS are listed on the cuda page whereas 3500 isnt. And i wouldn’t see any reason WHY theyd actually suppress cuda on a 3500 if the chipset was same. This means taht the card has not unlimited program registers (tey want cuda everywhere, its their world domination plan). Ergo its not a 8600 chipset.

remember we are going on the 9000 range in consumer cards now. (just got there) that would mean 3500 is 2 generations late.

QUOTE
Not like it’s a 3 year old chip.

No it really is outdated! The numbering on quadros confuse so many people. Theres no bargain sto be gained in the quardo ranges b takeing the next highest of a range get the newest in the lower tier.

Unless you are working on system where TESTING is expensive like a cat scan control unit. (where testing costs a lot, or even worse a spaceship design sytem where you need to mathematically proove your stuff wan where a 1 m rod can cost you a 1Million euros)

Wouldn’t be surprised if the articles i read were wrong considering it is quadro.

No oem 3700’s here so the cheapest is $1420 which is alot more then $450 for the 3500 espeically if your short on change.

You can get the 1700 for $800 but thats still almost twice the cost of the 3500 and all the benches i’ve seen put it on par or sometimes slightly better then the 3500 so I don’t see the reason to spend the extra for the same performance unless it performs alot better with GPGPU though that’s still breaking in atm.

Might look at getting a 3500 myself when I got some spare change, got an 8800gts atm but only 1/3 the performance of the 3500 in maya. Gonna softmod it to a quadro see if that shows any improvement, did that to my old x800 but it didn’t really do much when converted to a firegl

i saw 3700 for 1000$ recenty. And i saw a 1700 for 650$ (wait i found one even cheaper for about $400)

But 1700 is faster than 3500 when doing pixel shading and if your doing anykind of fx dev thats a ibg plus.

Soft mods havent worked for 3 full generations now.

QUOTE
No oem 3700’s here so the cheapest is $1420 which is alot more then $450 for the 3500 espeically if your short on change.

But then your taking the money form the wrong part, your directtly saving form yoru productivity.

by the way even 1420 us dollars is dirt cheap cosidering teh exchange rate of the $

If a item costs less than half a decent persons wages after taxes its dirt cheap.

Productivity isn’t as important when it’s only a hobby especially if your between jobs at the moment

So best price/performance with thte cheapest price is a big winner.

I’ve read a few things saying that the original 8800gts’s can be softmoded to an FX 4600 and say how so will see if that works or not once i get windows installed on another drive.

QUOTE(Rotor @ 03/20/08, 01:05 PM) [snapback]282943[/snapback]
Productivity isn’t as important when it’s only a hobby especially if your between jobs at the moment

Then get the 8800 it delivers most bang for the buck (or maybe 9600). But even 1700 is cheaper than 3500.

Forget quadros unless your actually working. If you are then it does not matter since tax systems in most western world enables you to take out teh difference in tax rebates.

So why take a card thats worse and costs in teh end equally much hwna you get a very good warranty for free on top.

QUOTE
I’ve read a few things saying that the original 8800gts’s can be softmoded to an FX 4600 and say how so will see if that works or not once i get windows installed on another drive.

Yes ive gotten 8800 to report ist a 4600 but it still perofrms as a 8800 and refuses to use 4600 drivers. So yes you can fool the os but gain no other benefit. It was hard to actually verify this unbtill i got a 4600 dragged next to it and made comparasions.
Most of those that softmod rarely have this commodity.

Already have an 8800 and over here the 1700 is 3x the price of an oem 3500 hence thinking about a 3500 as it will still be almost 3x the performance of the 8800 in maya.

okay, let me clear up about pricing. I am not allowed to post distributor pricing, so I will post market price. my price will be a little higher so I don’t get in trouble

FX1500 / FX1700 - $470
FX3500 - $670
FX3700 - $800
FX4600 - $1200
FX5600 - $2500

Doesn’t help if you can get an oem card of one and not the other.

http://www.staticice.com.au/cgi-bin/search…q=quadro+FX3500
Cheapest FX3500 $452

http://www.staticice.com.au/cgi-bin/search…q=quadro+FX1700
Cheapest FX1700 $772

With the slight difference in performance between the two for most things, being
strapped for cash it would seem to me its definately better getting an FX3500 &
just saving up for an FX1800 or whatever the next generation one will be which
would be a significant improvement in performance.

1800 is probably 1,5 years form now. Becaus ethey just bumped generation.

But the point bell is saying is that YOU CAN get a oem card for 1700 thet may mean manyual shopping but you can. And if your low on cash thats what your going to have to do.

Well find me a store in australia that sells an oem 1700 then.

That site has almost every store in the country that has a website on it and I can’t find any googling so other then phoning every store in each capital city I don’t know how to find an oem 1700

QUOTE(Rotor @ 03/28/08, 12:36 PM) [snapback]283335[/snapback]
That site has almost every store in the country that has a website on it and I can’t find any googling so other then phoning every store in each capital city I don’t know how to find an oem 1700

if you can save money by thet way then why not.

Well same holds true for Finnland yet it took me less than a day to find a supplier that could do this. But none of them actually told so on their website.

Also it took me less than 6 hours of work to drop the proce of my costs way below what the web said they were. work it. Usuaully smaller shops where the seller is a enthusisast are a good places to go to as they can really flex their muscles for special clients. Mind you not all stores do this, the bigger shop the less likely it is.

And whoever said you must stick to australia. Anyway i know for certain that any shop that uses hp as a partner can mange to get one worldwide. Besides even my old as dirt 1100 was very hard to get as there really want anybody to sell oem versions. When i finally found one that could the card was directly form hp and not even LOCAL hp. So why am i telling you this. Well it so is that the card broke and the worldwide warranty kicked in. A new card was waiting at my doorstep next morning 8.30 along with instructions on how to return the old card.

If you dont have much money you usually have much time instead. (if not then your spending time in wrong places)