Rebuilding a trimmed surface

Hi there, I am pretty new to Maya.
I am trying to create this odd shaped surface-
http://www.mike.dimension10.com/quickPost/trimsurf.jpg

after some pretty sketchy results using loft and boundary. I decided to project my curve onto a cylinder and trim it out.

Now I have the shape I want but it is difficult to control because it still has the CV's of the cylinder. So I am trying to rebuild the surface using trim convert but it is not looking so hot.

Can someone point me in the right direction.