Render Issue Shake 4.1 On Imac

Just purchased new iMac (20", OSX 10.5.5, 2.66GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, 4GB Ram, ATI Radeon HD 2600 Pro) and Shake 4.1. So as a relatively new user to Shake (1yr VFX experience in school and work) and new to Mac, imagine my shock when I called Apple about my issue and found out their support is limited to install issues only!

Anyhow I could go into that but won't, and will cut to the real issue!

Am working on HD footage. Shake would render between 50% and 75% of 369 frames and then crash out of flipbook. So got frustrated and quit for the day... came back next day and now won't render at all. Won't render in flipbook or render from a file out node. Went to console tab in shake no errors reported, its as if Shake is not even starting render process period! Bummer :wink:!

So before I use Apples solution, uninstall and re-install Shake... thats the extent of their knowledge base....

Was wondering if any of you gurus out there have a better solution, or an idea of what caused this issue. The system and program were purchased a whopping 3 days ago, and I don't want this to be an ongoing issue.

Cheers and thanx

hiya,

sorry to hear about your troubles, it's kinda hard to do remote trouble shooting on this though..

some things i'd try:

  • what output format are you rendering to? (avoid QT for trouble shooting).
  • what happens if you save the script and render it from the terminal (shake -v -exec path/to/script.shk -t 1-10)?
  • any difference if rendering with only 1 CPU?
  • what happens if you start up the shake GUI in verbose mode from the terminal? any error messages on rendering?
  • any network folders involved?
  • any custom installs (macros) or custom settings (.h files)?

just some ideas
++ chris

Thanx Chris,

Very indepth response much appreciated.

These same files rendered fine on a Linux system earlier. Older Version of Shake (4.00.0607) but slower computer with less ram. Was wondering if you would have a moment to expand on some of your possible solutions as I am very new to this OS and relatively new to Shake.

  • not sure what file type flipbook is using (is it changeable?)
  • file out node was rendering out jpeg as a test only - neither flip nor fileout render starts
  • haven't tried rendering from terminal yet will after I do this
  • hmmmmm in Mac how would I choose rendering using one CPU or is that done within Shake :wink:
  • GUI Verbose?
  • as I did when rendering on Linux system I am pulling images over usb 2.0 from external drive.
  • and yes custom .h involved also previously used when on Linux.

So if you or anyone else out there has the time to expand on any of this you have know Idea how appreciated that would be..... long story and I won't bore you !

Cheers
Have a great weekend :wink:

QUOTE(zem @ 09/26/08, 11:21 AM) [snapback]292384[/snapback]
hiya,

sorry to hear about your troubles, it's kinda hard to do remote trouble shooting on this though..

some things i'd try:

  • what output format are you rendering to? (avoid QT for trouble shooting).
  • what happens if you save the script and render it from the terminal (shake -v -exec path/to/script.shk -t 1-10)?
  • any difference if rendering with only 1 CPU?
  • what happens if you start up the shake GUI in verbose mode from the terminal? any error messages on rendering?
  • any network folders involved?
  • any custom installs (macros) or custom settings (.h files)?

just some ideas
++ chris

QUOTE(vfxHenchman @ 09/26/08, 10:12 PM) [snapback]292391[/snapback]
- not sure what file type flipbook is using (is it changeable?)

i'm guessing here as well, but it's most likely uncompressed to ram. i just mentioned quicktime because you're running a very new OS version, and sometimes quicktime issues crop up.

QUOTE
- file out node was rendering out jpeg as a test only - neither flip nor fileout render starts

ok, definitely not a quicktime issue then

QUOTE
- haven't tried rendering from terminal yet will after I do this

good, let us know the output

QUOTE
- hmmmmm in Mac how would I choose rendering using one CPU or is that done within Shake :wink:

in the render or flipbook or render dialog, set maxThread to 1 (you can also do this in the globals or in a .h file)

QUOTE
- GUI Verbose?

just a fancy way of saying starting the GUI from the terminal with "shake -v"

QUOTE
- as I did when rendering on Linux system I am pulling images over usb 2.0 from external drive.

ok, that sounds fine.. but try a short test with a script that only uses generated footage anyway (checker, ramp etc)

QUOTE
- and yes custom .h involved also previously used when on Linux.

hmm, try disabling that for a moment (ie put them all in a folder outside the nreal directory called disabled, or compress them as zip files to make the moving back faster).

i'm really just guessing here, but sounds like an issue with some preferences/.h files..
best way is to make a backup of the whole nreal folder, delete it and make a new clean install of shake, then check if everything works, and then move the .h files back and see if the problem reappears. shouldnt take more then half an hour or so.

++ c.

ps: just read that 10.5.5 has some issues with graphic drivers, specially radeon or opengl stuff..

so if you might want to install/clone a test system with 10.5.4 or earlier to an external firewire disk and run shake on that before you start pulling your hair.

just an idea
++ chris

what custom .h files are you using and what is inside them?

QUOTE(zem @ 09/27/08, 07:34 PM) [snapback]292447[/snapback]
ps: just read that 10.5.5 has some issues with graphic drivers, specially radeon or opengl stuff..

so if you might want to install/clone a test system with 10.5.4 or earlier to an external firewire disk and run shake on that before you start pulling your hair.

just an idea
++ chris

in response to both zem and beaker :wink:

Hmmmm :wink:

Okay well back after having to rush out of town for the weekend, and yesterday filed in some HD footage and just tried (without success) to do a flipbook of footage with no extraneous nodes, just a straight flippy of it. LOL now I believe this should work no custom .h's involved or anything. And yes no render still, same thing no flipbook at all.... so maybe it is 10.5.5 issue...... haven't tried (10.5.4)yet and well frustration is kicking in :wink:.

Unistalled and reinstalled Shake, no change. I guess my real issue here is that render worked initially (although it crashed out around frame 250 of 369), and I wish I was more of an IT guy but am not (yes starts to rant here). It seems to me I have purchased a very sexy system and yes some very verbose software (that doesn't go unrecognized here) that is not supported by the seller (Apple) steam starts coming out of ears LOL. Now all this footage and nodes etc rendered out fine on the Linux systems at school, but won't render here on this new swanky system. So my intro to Mac has left me less than enamored with Apple. OK rant over :wink: Also tried to render on demo of Shake software on my old Linux system at home and rendered fine albeit with demo watermark of course......

So can .h files effect rendering even if they are not in tree of footage being rendered? Would I have been better off with an Nvidia graphics card, if it was available for this particular iMac? And should a simple render really be this complicated (fully understanding that Shake is a powerful and complex program)? The console tab in Shake shows no errors during Shake launch other than some .h files are not being loaded (ones not used in composite being rendered).

I fully appreciate any responses to my post so far, and yes haven't tried all suggestions yet, but my desire to become an IT expert is low LOL as apposed to my desire to do compositing which is high. Maybe the 2 are synonymous with each other, boy I hope not.

So please keep the suggestions coming in I will try the ones which fall into my knowledge base and am thankful for any and all suggestions. And I appreciate that remote trouble shooting is tough...... and a crap shoot at best :wink:

Frustrated new Apple customer.
Lance :wink:

well, that's what you get for buying an old unsupported software that used to be 5000bucks for 500
seriously, i'm pretty disappointed myself about apple not even fixing the most basic problems (such as quicktime), but then again, i'm happy that it's affordable.

when the first render crashed, did you run 10.5.5 already? any other changes since then?

QUOTE(vfxHenchman @ 09/30/08, 04:43 PM) [snapback]292594[/snapback]
So can .h files effect rendering even if they are not in tree of footage being rendered?

yes, they can contain other info but macros.. and they can even prevent the app to start.

QUOTE
Would I have been better off with an Nvidia graphics card, if it was available for this particular iMac?

possibly, but who knows.. i doubt it's a graphic card issue though (did you try the command line render of a simple ramp->brightness->fileouttodesktop.#.jpeg script?)

QUOTE
And should a simple render really be this complicated (fully understanding that Shake is a powerful and complex program)?

the render is not complicated at all, all you're having is a config/compability issue.

QUOTE
The console tab in Shake shows no errors during Shake launch other than some .h files are not being loaded (ones not used in composite being rendered).

well, that means you dont have a clean install..
did those .h files come from the linux machine?
rename the nreal folder in your home directory to nreal-old, and restart shake. also delete your cache folder (forgot where it is by default, check the manual /tmp/xxx maybe)

QUOTE
I fully appreciate any responses to my post so far, and yes haven't tried all suggestions yet, but my desire to become an IT expert is low LOL as apposed to my desire to do compositing which is high. Maybe the 2 are synonymous with each other, boy I hope not.

well, if you get to more demanding jobs very helpful if you know some basic scripting. but speaking from my experience, yes, trouble shooting computer problems is part of the job (maybe if you have a really big shop there's somebody there to do it for you).

if you cant find the problem, i'd take an old firewire drive, install a clean system, a shake, and check if renders work.
i know it sounds silly, but it hardly takes half an hour (and you can grab some coffee while doing it).
if yes, you know that it's just a config issue and can try to troubleshoot (or just use that system for comping). if no, you know it's a system problem and you should consider using an older OSX version

++ c.

Okay LOL.

Call me daft LOL, but I thought to launch Shake from the Terminal rather than from the program icon, as I would normally on a Linux based system. And what do you know...... I think my problem is overcome.... think being the operative word. Flip book works WAHOO! Test render from fileout node ( only did the first 50 frames) works so far.

So if Chris or beaker suggested this and I overlooked it I apologize but thank you for all your input (or output as the case may be) :wink:.

That being said maybe one of you could briefly explain why this would be .......

I will continue to launch Shake 4.1 within OS 10.5.5 from the terminal. I will let you know whether this is a total solution soon.

Cheers and Thanx :wink:

I will continue to use these boards as I am very grateful for all the feedback!

QUOTE(vfxHenchman @ 09/30/08, 09:18 PM) [snapback]292602[/snapback]
That being said maybe one of you could briefly explain why this would be .......

Different environment variables?
QUOTE
well, if you get to more demanding jobs very helpful if you know some basic scripting. but speaking from my experience, yes, trouble shooting computer problems is part of the job

This is something people sometimes fail to understand if you work with pen and paper you should know how pen and paper works in different conditions. But while everyone understands thsi magically to them for computers it does not apply. I say if you work on computers KNOW computers. Its not actually all that much work to actually pick up something useful every week or so. In my mind it shows high disrespect for the work you do if you dont learn ins and outs of the computer.

QUOTE(Joojaa @ 09/30/08, 11:47 AM) [snapback]292606[/snapback]
Different environment variables?

In my mind it shows high disrespect for the work you do if you dont learn ins and outs of the computer.

:wink:

Couldn't agree more, and I know PC's in a fairly deep way(built pc's and know it's OS decently), being new to both Linux and Mac OS, I will continue to learn more and more about it's ins and outs........ as time permits and look forward to understanding more and more about it .... sometimes like anyone though LOL you just want to get done what needs getting done hehe....

Mac OS I will devour you and suck more and more knowledge about you into my grey matter

Thanx for the very relative comment mate...... I can stand to be put in my place occasionally...

Cheers
Lance

"humour still in tact or is that craziness setting in!"

well, glad it all works again, but you must understand that i feel a bit confused because i wrote in my very first reply:

QUOTE(zem @ 09/26/08, 07:21 PM) [snapback]292384[/snapback]
- what happens if you start up the shake GUI in verbose mode from the terminal? any error messages on rendering?

also, i'm still not sure if you have checked your .h files..
personally i'd try to really solve the problem, because you can be sure it will come back again and haunt you in the middle of a deadline.

just dont come crying to us
++ c.

QUOTE(zem @ 09/30/08, 12:50 PM) [snapback]292612[/snapback]
just dont come crying to us
++ c.

Hey Chris :wink:

Well think I must have been tired since I had been trying to resolve the issue first on Linux (other prob) and then on the new iMac. Went back and sure enough you mentioned launching GUI in verbose mode and trying renders. Hehe I miss read it and thought you were strictly talking about rendering from terminal! LOL and wasn't sure how to do that - not understanding what you meant as I am not up on all the tech speak (am learning fast though) ...... I always thought of that as launching the program from terminal :wink: Anyhoo not to worry got the lingo down now. And as I said all was appreciated :wink:

Now if I am to check .h's should I look for ones that specifically have "macros" missing and no fx's and eliminate one at a time. Is that the best course of action given they are all installed and it seems to be working fine in verbose mode? And is it quite common for Shake to run fine in verbose mode and not from launching from a desktop icon. Seems to me we always ran Shake at school in verbose mode......

Cheers and thanx again mate :wink:

Promises not to come crying and to over time resolve issue......... but will come back with many other questions to the forums over time :wink:

A forum of learning :wink: