Renderman v. Maya v. Mental Ray

I'm looking for some opinions on renderers for production. We're using Maya's right now and we want something more reliable and well, just better. There are pros and cons to every program, so I wanted to hear how each fares in film production for those of you out there with the experience.
These posts mention that Maya is reworking their renderer for a future version, but what exactly are they doing and when is that supposed to happen? Does Alias list what they are doing for future updates on the web?
Renderman obviously has proven itself, but how is the integration with Maya?
Also, when is Mental Ray coming for Maya?

I found a great site to see for yourself;
www.thelightomelette.com go to radiosity fakes where you can check out arnold(maya) vs mental ray (both quite realistic!)
No word on either release dates though.
Maos.

I thought Arnold was for lightwave & MAX!!!

being ported to Maya too as far as im told....but it will be a while probably....look how long its taken so far for Mental Ray to get ported over to maya....

I am in the prpocess of learning MTOR. I have comleatly abandoned the Maya renderer. Mtor blends seamlessly with Maya and its speed and results cant be beat. MTOR (Maya to Renderman) and Renderman Artists Tools RAT work similar to the multilister. You dont need to write script, Slim, a Gui enables you controll and create the atributes of shaders. Rman chews up large files with no complaints without large amounts of ram.
The negative is in the learning curve. It is very difficult to learn not because its hard to master, but the documentation is thin and geared to those with more of a programing background. If you can find someone thhat knows Rat it will be much easier. On the positive side of learning Pixar customer support is great, they usualy return emails by the next day. But onece you understand it I think the workflow is simpler than Maya's. The speed of Rman is amazing.

Just my $ .02
Dan

Dan

Yes, Renderman simply rocks!
Just a few things:
1. No raytracing! You can kindda fake reflections, but, in my opinion (im new to renderman myself), even if you get the reflections to look decent (im no talking about planar or spherical reflections), the process is very slow. With the environment thingy, mtor needs to render the scene 6 !!! times, for every reflection. It takes ages, and i wasnt able till now to get a real cool reflection.
Yes, BMRT would be it, its just that i wasnt able to integrate it. Is this solution actualy ment to work on NT?
2. You can't render any paint fx stuff
3. Fur looks great but if you animate it, you wont get any fur animation out of mtor. It should work, but it doesnt.
I still prefere the hypershade, maybe becouse i know it inside out, but Slim is quite handy too.
Renderman definitely rocks the house
My humble opinion
Cheers

It has its drawbacks.
I am not aware of any way to do raytracing efficently with large scenes. When the files start getting up there in size the time cost is just too high. Is there a speedy raytracer something that will keep up with Rman?
I tried some test renders of a 50 meg .mb file, just geometry, in Maya. The results were 46 frames in 24 hours. I did the same file with Mtor on the same machines ( no rib boxes )and got just under 800 frames in 24 hours.
Just my limited experience.
Ive heard rumors about a new renderer for Maya4 that would be nice.

Dan

actually, if you want to do raytracing and radiosity (in the renderman world) BMRT is free (!). There's also lots of other renderman compliant renders coming your way these days ( http://www.dotcsw.com ).

Beyond being a great render, which has consistantly proved it's worth for 12 years, it's also an amazingly well thought out and robust specification (see Renderman Companion) which has left it open for expansion with almost no fundimental changes to the spec. It really is rapidly becoming the HTML of the 3d world.

As for renderman fur (w/animation), Shave and a Haircut (http://www.joealter.com/new.html - shameless plug) will soon be available...

regards,
joe alter

It has to have animation of hair Pixar does it. Wan't stuart little done with Rman?

Stuart Little was indeed done with Renderman + Maya. They used MEL scripts to set up the fur in Maya (not done with built-in fur) and then used a custom DSO in Renderman to generate the RiCurves for the fur at rendertime.

Even better than the real thing.

no wonder some of these movies cost 50 - 100 mil.

payin' for software development on professional wages ain't pretty.