Hi guys, please give my humble model some crits
She’s meant to be a futuristic gear-pilot !!!
I modeled her using Maya’s Nurbs and SubD. Oh course, I wasn’t aiming for realism but a cartoony look. Modeling is 95 % done and not yet textured!!! I still have to add eyebrows, hair and stuff.
and some happy and angry shot of her… (I’m planning to animate her afterward…)
Please tell me what you think. this is my third attempt at modelling a humanoid. The last two weren’t that successful… and i need to learn fast so I can get a job heehehe.. im starving
any comment/suggestion will be greatly appreciated. If you want to see more pics, close-up, wireframe etc just tell me and i’ll be happy to post.
sweet - i like her. nice face/eyes/mouth -
i dont like the hair so much but we know hairs a real pain.
did you use cloth or model the clothes (shirt)? i like the shirt. very nice though, russ, (another starving artist)
Wow. I have to say, I’m extremely impressed with this model. I can think of no real modelling improvements. Maybe if I were to offer ONE suggestion, it would be to work with the hair a bit more. Make it less of a "clump mass: kind of look to it. (You know, like using Paint FX, or layers and layers of hair transparencys. )Other than all of that, though, I’de say its looking pretty sweet.
Hair is a pain in the a$$ i know, and i am planning to remodel her hair into little strips with transparency maps. thanks for pointing that out
I used geometry for her clothes. I don’t think its necssary to use cloth for this one unless it is a dress or a long gown. Her clothes is fairly stiff, mainly leather and lycra, so it should be OK to use geometry.
Urp: thank you for noticing that, but i intentionally model the hand (and foot) bigger so it would fit in with her large head hehehe…
oh and i forgot to post this crucial pic!!! this is the rear view of my model, yummy!
nice model…but did you design the character your self?
I’m also doing some hair, if you want i could post a screen shot of it…if you like it I can give of my suggestions as to how I didi it…Not that I have done this before…
btw,is the the hip area subD, othewise Nurbs…then I would have questioned trim->fillet/blend ?
Edited by yinako on 04/24/01 07:10:03 AM.
I love your model so much. Since there is eastern anime style of model. I like the design of her costume too. Just so nice. very nice. The mouth, the lip is the hardest part, and you did a reallyreally great job. I am serious. Only the hair is a bit unfinished. But as you said, only 95%. I don’t think I can give you any suggestions. I agree what Urp said. The hands are in gloves, which will have the illusion of too big and too long. But that is easy to fix. Keep up the good work!!!
once again thank you for the positive feedbacks. I designed the model and the costume myself. I’m planning to build the entire crew and i nearly finish another model which i’m going to post very soon.
The hip area is subdiv as well as her face. but i’m currently using my school comp and dont have access to my files. I’ll post it a screenschot tomorrow as well as her wireframes.
Thanks for pointing out those mistakes. I will work on it soon.
Yinako: I would love to see the screenshots of your model
I agree with some of the others … this is a very good model! I wouldn’t mind taking a peek at the wireframe for her head and shoulder area to see how you handled a few things. The hair looks ok to me - except it needs a better shader applied. Also, the collar bone does protrude a little too much.
But … those are really nitpicky things. I think it looks awesome. I wish my models turned out half this good.
I did it using Maya subdivision surface using only level 0 edit. I heard that there seems to be a problem when you try to transfer UV if you do level 1 edit and above (you will lose the hierarchical edit!).. Anyway, I’m quite happy with the model layout.
Kirt: I’m sure, with practice, you’ll be able to build good models too.
How did you construct the poly surface before converting to subd’s and get this wonderfull sub d model without bad 5 sided regions. I mean they are all quads…I can’t seem to master this especially when building the legs!
this will sound picky… but there is something about her torso - too compressed, stomach too short maybe?- Some people are built this way, but you are going for ideal proportions, eh?
Small critique on a great model, yah.. hair is a pain.
construct your poly using only 4 sided regions (rectangles) avoid using triangles or more than 4 sides as this will make the model complicated. When you look at the hierarchical edit, you should only see level 0 and 1. A good trick would be to build your leg in nurbs, convert to poly using control points, and convert to sub D from there, so you can attach it to the body. and the leg will all be four sides because you use nurbs from the beginning.
The notion that triangles and 5 sided polygons are to be avoided is false. Break away from the limitations which nurbs have brought, one of the reasons studios use sub-ds is so the wireframe can follow the contours of the face (not just the muscles), this includes the corners of the lips and the wrinkles around the eyes. One look at the wireframes of Pixar’s human models and you will quickly notice the gazillion triangles and 5 siders. Since when is Pixar wrong, trust me, they know what they’re doing.
Sorry for straying too much off topic, this is suppose to be a critique. I just had to get it out of my system.