This is a 3D short two fellow-students and I did as final task in our second semester at the GERMAN FILM SCHOOL (www.filmschool.de).
The first semester there is about traditional (2D) animation (the semester movie is on my site, too) and in the second semester we where taught 3D (mainly Maya).
This short was done at the end of the second semester as, well, exam about our software and 3D theory knowledge. It took us about two and a half month to do it.
We used Maya, Photoshop, AfterFX, Shake, DeepPaint, Edit and ProTools.
What do you think of it?
Having your ending credits longer than your actual animated piece is not a good thing… last thing people want to download is all of that aswell…
The pacing of your story is too slowly executed… I feel you could have shaved off at least 15 seconds maybe more… The story itself looks like it needs some work to make it more funny.
The animation is very ridged and look more like an animatic rather than final animation… it looks like you spent maybe 2 days or less on that. The characters have no sense of weight, anticipation seems non-existant… no squash and stretch that I could see…
You can completely cut the beginning with the sign… thats not needed at all.
When the box gets thrown in with the anteater inside its way too slow and the anteater should have been boucing all over inside it. Maybe you could have shown the box bouncing then cut to the Anteater sitting there dazed, and shakes its head hard to clear its dizziness…
The can could be rolling about a bit more maybe banging agaist the side of the truck…
I`d go into much more detail but I have to finish up the animation on my current project… oh and I am just really picky about animation…
Camera was ok but it could have done with some better angles to express certain extremes better… for instance when the Ant sees the anteater and screams…
Modelling.. this isn`t a strength of mine but it seemed ok bt needs improvement…
texturing and lighting… that was good too but also needs work…
Yeah, it begins to feel slightly silly after you realize its the same persons over and over again… Altough if your intent is to find job as a end credits designer then its fine
Even for and end credits designer it`d be too much
having 2 minutes 43 seconds of end credits and 30 seconds of opening credits when the animation is only around 1 minute 30 seconds (probably 1 minute if edited better)
Sorry I`m being harsh but I learned the hard way aswell when I first posted here and my credits were only 10 seconds for the opening and 25 seconds for the ending…
if you submit to film festivals, they usually only give you 7 seconds for credits. anything longer, and they chop the whole thing off. most of them don’t like scrolling credits either (just fyi)
Sorry for my late reply. I’m well aware of the credits problem. I’ll make a shorter version available soon (with just a plate at the end).
A little explanation:
We had shorter credits in the beginning, but two of us (we were two guy and a girl) didn’t like them from a design point of view. Plus our school headmaster didn’t like them either. He found them too fast and too small, just like the two of us. He said it doesn’t matter if they get a bit longer, but more readable. Well, we knew better when we started for a second time, but we didn’t care and so we created very readable credits, that are way too long. But it was a fun thing to do, although we were and are aware that the are too long.
Any critiques beside the already known too long credits?
Alex
P.S.: THX QtNFlufy. Good critique, I’ll work on it.