The Difference Between Sub'ds and LowPolys is?

coming from 3dmax background

i have a diffcult , to find out about the difference

between Sub'ds modelling and LowPolygon modelling !!

in max , i was had a one method for modeling ( meshEdit ) plus MeshSmoth ..

so ..

any one of you guys , help me to have a knowledge about this ..

i am very good modeler , but not understand the differ !!

(sorry for bad language )

thanks

Bonjour st_petersburg,

I too come from a max background!

In fact there is no difference. MeshSmooth and Geo Approx do the same thing on polygons. They both subdivide the object, using the Catmull-Clark algorithm.

What is different is the tool itself. In max it's an operator (Modifier), and in XSI it's a property. Each software offer different options. In XSI you can have your subdivision level based on the distance from the camera.

One thing that I think is missing in XSI is the ability to set a different level of tesselation for rendering and in the viewports. This when the +/- keys are handy. Also, in XSI you can't freeze the Geo Approx, but you have an option to create a new object that will be subdivided (with Duplicate using Geo Approx).

So in the end, when you use MeshSmooth in 3ds max you are actually doing sub-d modeling. It's just labeled differently.

Hope this helps
Salutations - Cheers
Bernard Lebel

je vous remerci atyss !!

thanks for this ( FASTHELP !! ) Atyss

but you hadn't ansewr my main question :

IN GENERAL

What Is the Diffrence ( general diffrence at all ) between

Subd's And Lowpoly ..... ?

and forget what max and xsi is ....

( I belive It is The same process of work !! )

Where the diffrence lies ?

thanks in advance

wait ..

i may understand from your reply that the process is like this :

1- firstly , do lowpoly object

2- secondly , do subd's on it ..

so it is a levels of work processing

not a two diffrent methods , is that right ?


with not disturb you

you said

( subdivision based on the camer distane )

could you little explain , and what the advantage of this ?

thanks !!

In XSI you can have your subdivision level based on the distance from the camera. <<

??? How?

Markus

st_petersburg:
You are right. Basically sub-d is a concept that allows you to model in low resolution, then to smooth things up when its come to rendering. Well, in practice a low res model for broad cast can be up to 15 000 polygons (or even more), depending on the level of detail you want.

Markman:
Check this post, it explains it all:

http://www.highend3d.com/boards/showthread...&Main=85347

The only thing is that you'll have to scrub the timeline to see the subdivision changes when they occur.

Hope this helps
Salutations - Cheers
Beranrd Lebel

Ahh, okay, an expression.
I thought you meant a feature like viewdependant tesselation or so.

Thanks

Markus

Well it's not an implemented feature but does the same thing!

Bernard