Updated character please critique

So here is a character that I have currently been working on, the textures are not final but the modeling is. I am wanting some creative criticism before I begin the blendshapes for facial expressions. I have attempted to exaggerate the size of the eyes somewhat without him looking strange. please give your opinion of proportions and so on. I have been looking at him so long I cannot give myself an honest critique at this point.
http://www.geocities.com/sayheytonate/lilB…FaceUpdate.html > http://www.geocities.com/sayheytonate/lilB…FaceUpdate.html

Thankyou in advanced,
Nate Bucholtz

I’m not sure if its just my computer or not but the link didn’t work when I tried clicking on it. Although if you copy and paste the link to the address bar it will work. I can make a character come to life on a computer but I can’t create a working link. go figure .

Hey nate - lookin a little better - I would take a second look at the lips themselvs - they could use some more definition and more import depth. when they start opening and closing you will want it to look better. Also i would reassess the hair - you might rather go for the nurb approach unless you can get better results from fur. good luck CCADer.

Is this supposed to be a realistic looking kid or not? Whether it is, or not, it looks like he’s bugeyed, or stoned =P hehehe.
And I don’t really like the hair, it kind of looks like he has no hairline and the color is way too bright and you can see spots of his scalp which makes it look like he’s balding in places. Also his nosebridge is crooked and his forehead looks really flat. His ear is also shaped like a little discus around the perimeter. Lastly, his eyes are slanted downward, which adds to his bugeye look.

I’d also like to know if you are going for a cute look or not, because at the moment he’s not very cute to me.
I won’t comment on the texturing since it’s still a WIP.

-Lancelet

This is obviously not supposed to be a realistic-looking kid. Go back to working on your virtual girlfriend, you caustic dork.

To original poster: Pull the eyes together a little closer and adjust the bridge of the nose to fit w/eyes better. Are you going for a sad look?

Frodo

You really like to start flame threads don’t you? Do everyone a favor and shut the FCK up. Or post some of your work since you’re such a Fcking expert. I’m sorry, I can’t come up with your witty posts like “Your animation Rocks, but your modelling blows”

Last, I checked, this was a critique forum. Not a “critique my work and sugar coat it” forum.

Your account is nothing more than a lame flame account, so go back to playing with yourself.

-Lance

Quit fighting…I just want some help…I don’t want sugar coated advice. I want my work to look good so I want honesty and everyone has a right to an opinion…so love eachother …but anyway…

Lancelet had some valid points. No the kid isn’t suppose to be life like but I don’t want to exaggerate to the point of it looking strange. I posted a work in progress image next to my original pic to show what I have done so far. By the way Nanoform the hair is paint effects not fur. I have not updated the hair yet so the new image is bald. By Wednesday I hope to have the new hair up and running. If anyone has any suggestions about hair please let me know. I never animated with hair before. Does paint effects hair look real when it moves or should I try fur. I looked at other post on the highend boards and it seems like its just a personal preference. Also in the new pic do the eyes look better? I also defined the lips somewhat (they will be more evident once textures are applied). The nose is upturned alittle and the cheeks are alittle puffier. And the kid isn’t suppose to look sad, but that is a blank stare before I add emotions with facial expressions. Tell me what ya think. same webpage…
http://www.geocities.com/sayheytonate/lilB…FaceUpdate.html > http://www.geocities.com/sayheytonate/lilB…FaceUpdate.html

copy and paste if link doesn’t work by clicking on it.

Nate

I dont know man - I like the first alot more - the only thing that looks any better is the sides of the eyes are covered a little more - but they look worse for the wear - can i see your sketches for this mod??

i agree…the first ones much better…has a doll like appearance to it whixh works well, where as the second one just looks odd.

thanks

leach

I suppose what you’re looking to do is make him hyper-realistic. I also make my characters this way so I can lend some advice. The main probelm that I saw was with the eyes, they need to be shaped more like almonds and straightened out. Also they look too big, with the eyes that size, I thought you were going for a toon look, but you had eye lids and bags, which made it look more realistic.
Nanoform has already quoted on the lips, so I’ll move onto the nose, which I think should be a tad shorter and the lines around the bridge could be straightened out, because I distinctly saw something crooked there as well. The hair looked really frissy to me at first glance, which is the result of painteffects. That’s why I tend to stay away from it, instead, I suggest you use a bunch of small nurb surfaces to get the hair you want. But if you plan on staying with painteffects, then tone down the color a bit, because it seems too bright in my opinion.

Basically everything I’ve said here is the same as I said before except this is for people who are more concerned with my presentation than my advice.

Here’s and example of a boy I’m working on, you can see the proportions I was talking about. whether this is the style you’re looking for or not, you will soon realize that keeping the ratio or proportions together, will make for a better head.

Excuse the roughness
http://members.home.net/lancelet/kid1.jpghttp://members.home.net/lancelet/kid1.jpg

Yawn. Rarely flame, do a search. Enough, must respond to my real girlfriend’s phonecall.

Frodo