Watter in a bottle

Hi Just make a bottle of wine and I want to simulate to have liquid inside the bottle, I am not trying to animate it, just to simulate the fluid into the bottle.....what is the best way to simulate this?

I am running Maya 6.0 and mental ray included

thanks in advance

if you are not trying to animate it, why not just model the liquid surface? You can also use the ocean shader with very liitle waves and turn on refactions to get a nice look too.

What does the liquid need to do, in your mind, to be "convincing?" Grab yourself a bottle of the stuff, and before you drink too much of it .. .. look at it and ask yourself, "what makes it look like wine to me?"

You might have no need for a fluid-simulation. You might decide that a simple cylinder, appropriately colored and nested inside the bottle, is all you need. Or you might decide that ... "what's really going to 'make it' for me is refraction." Or maybe, specular highlights. Frosting on the glass? Or whatever. My point is that first and foremost you must first decide what you are shooting for.

Remember also, if your requirements are not complicated, do not make them so. If the wine is not the center of attention in the shot, then once the viewer groks that "okay, this is a bottle of wine," you've got it, unless something is so jaring that it "draws the viewer's eye" and makes him say, "Now waitaminit, there's something vewwy skwewy about this so-called bottle of wine!" Sometimes, well-intentioned efforts to "add detail" actually cause this, so don't do more than is necessary.

Hi

well thanks for your reply, what I am tring to express is the photorealistic scene of a glass of wine sided in a table and a crishtmas bell besides..... so I am felling a little stucked in this part of creating or modeling the wine inside the bottle.........as the bottle as by side I am wondering how to model the object first....then asign a shader maybe ocean shader? but want to look the reflexion and refraccion as the real word....

sugestions?

thanks

"I say again"... ... what do you want? If you are doing a scene of static, unmoving wine in a bottle, then perhaps you don't need to do anything at all in particular to produce the effect that the bottle is full of wine. I'm looking at a (delicious!) bottle of wine right now and, since the bottle is slightly tinted and there's a label on it, no particular features of the liquid stand-out at all. In other words, a "liquid" model is not required, not in the slightest, to give the appearance that this bottle is (uh, as of now, was...) full of delicious wine.

Whatever reflections there might be, in this case with this bottle, exist only on the glass. And refraction, through the liquid, is once again not an issue. Maybe the very simplest solution, and I am being perfectly serious here, is to disregard these things. You don't need to face them to produce a convincing picture, and if you don't need to face them, I always say "don't!"

Seriously again, the word "photorealistic" can very easily become a code-word for self-flagellation. You start doing stuff in a shot because you think you have to do it, and then you start setting-up the shots in such a way that you have to do it! An equally satisfactory solution to your problem would be to "think of the scene like a studio photographer would." viz... "Both reflections and refractions are very likely to cause 'hot spots' on the film or distracting bright-spots on the tabletop. Therefore I'd move the lights so that the reflections were indirect, and I'd rotate the bottle slightly so that the label was more readable." Now the entire problem is solved by means of avoidance, and if you feel somehow that this is cheating ... don't. Oh, okay, it's cheating, but cheating is sometimes good.

If you insist upon getting the refraction and the reflection working, you'll find that you probably have to do it in two separate steps... modeling the wine as though the bottle consisted of nothing but a column of wine, and then adding the specular-reflections on top of that. There may be an easier way but I don't know what it would be. I'd just avoid it.

"jm2cw, of course."

no point i spspending 99% of the time on something that contributes less that 1% to the image... In general people will not notice, if theres even anything to notice. And true a red wine bottle doe snot cast much in causastics. and because the surface is static theres no need to simulate it eiter. juwst latjhe the wine.

Remeber photo realim does not mean to do things like its photographicaly real, or physicaly but to make it LOOK like its real... The difference is HUGE.

Truth is that we dont have computers that are capable of simulating even the simplest of things very accurately on a purely physacaly accurate levell. Its allways a GRODSS approximation, so even alambert shader isnt thatmuch furter form rue behaivour forma dgs shader on a tryuly ABSOLUTE scale, just becauseuse thye stilll are way of base.