I use Maya and I'm impressed by its modeling tools such as the Subdivision surfaces but its renderer is really bad. I here XSI has got a similar modeling tools in version 1.5
My question is.. Are the subdivision modeling tools in XSI any good ( and if they are, are they better the Maya’s )
They SubD’s are similar in usability, but XSI has the advantage of being able to texture and render what it makes…at least it is much easier and more dependable.
I think the intruduction of SubD’s is a very significant developement. Maya has always had the reputation of having a better modeler, while Soft is stronger in animation and of course they certainly have a better rendering solution.
We’ll now that SubD’s are becoming the preferred method for most animators, the modeling issue may be up for grabs. SubD’s are so different from surface modeling that Maya has no longer has any kind of advantage, that would draw users any more than Soft’s SubD’s.
Soft can already animate and render quite well. If SubD’s continue on and dominate, then it will be hard for people to keep up this DOA crap, since all areas of animation are very strong (1) modeling (2) animating (3) Rendering.
what gets me thinking though is why this technology took soo long to catch on.
subds have been around for about 10-15 years now.
…imagine what they would be like now if it caught on earlier…( maya would probably have workable texture solutions for subds.
I love XSI’s subDs… there are a number of ways you can apply subdivisions depending on your needs, and the tools are fast and effective. They aren’t perfect yet, but they are pretty damn good, I am doing almost everything polygonally now.
If you want more info hop over to soft’s site and you will find tutorials, movie-demos and can order a demo CD, so you can get a feel for how they are and how they work for you personally.
"I love XSI’s subDs… there are a number of ways you can apply subdivisions depending on your needs, and the tools are fast and effective. They aren’t perfect yet, but they are pretty damn good, I am doing almost everything polygonally now. "
I agree. Just the general concept of using Sub-Ds for modelling is a great tool. Much better than NURBS surfaces for complex characters.
I find myself making most things in polygons also, particularly because I get the great smoothness like I want with NURBS, but I don’t have to worry myself about editing the complex structures.
I have got to smile about the concensus on how good
subD’s are.
I do agree and just so nobody misinterprets me I am an
XSI animator
Lightwave started using subD’s (metanurbs) at
least 5 years ago, and i remember many people
turning their noses up at them because they
“are not real nurbs”. Definitely the snobby highend
mentality of the time.
You have a good point rotifer, many of us in 3d have a bad habit of jumping on a popular bandwagon instead of forming our opinions carefully and with an open mind
I am not a lightwave artist but I remember mucking around a bit with metanurbs back when they came out, and thinking they were pretty phat. Nowdays lightwave is again pushing new tech ahead of the rest by incorporating HDRI into the renderer. It just goes to show that some of the best innovations can go unnoticed by the majority.
Sometimes I think that our community is a little too dazzled by marketing hype for our own good…
I would have to agree with the whole lightwave issue - they had it right ages ago, although they never got the whole uv thing happening - untill now - which leads me to my next point - polygons may be fantastic for modelling, but texturing is a right pain in the butt. This has sort of steared me away from them for quite a while, as uv editing can take many times longer than modelling itself.
In response to the original post, I’ve used them both and can assure you maya’s polys are kind of funny compared to xsi’s - matter of prefference aside and all the rest of it. AW is kind of famous for throwing in useless cosmetic features - like trax for instance. I guess i should say this, on the surface maya’s subds will seem deeper and so on, but when you have to get a job done “no matter what it is” - XSI’s implementation of polys is far superior - when it comes time to texture you will know what i mean, and you will most definately know what i mean when it comes time to render - less process, and a better result. Of course people will tell you maya’s are “true” subds… - but of course they render as polys… making them exactly the same at crunce time - only worse.
BTW - the final fantasy comment earlier - just thought i would point out a majority of the more impressive (and i do mean majority) models were scanned in - much like most of the stuff you see at the movies.
BTW - the final fantasy comment earlier - just thought i would point out a majority
of the more impressive (and i do mean majority) models were scanned
in - much like most of the stuff you see at the movies.
Final Fantasy models where not scanned in, all sets, props and chatacter have been made from scratch.
All modelled in Maya, rendered in Renderman.
Maya polygons tools have a lot of fuctionality that XSI doesnt have, and the package is way more stable (maya).
Softimage is still in a good track bat is not there yet.
I love Maya polygons and I use them a lot, never had problems with them.
We render most of out project with RenderMan, so as now we don’t use Maya subD at least until that MTOR doesnt support them 4.5.
Anyway use whatever you like and whatever get you a job, I’m personally a Maya user and like it. I still find XSI slow (on IRIX in particular) and the UI is too clumpsi (bottom too big, the properti editor is hard to navigate and I miss the ability to connect nodes directly).
Just my .02c, and so far there is no major production using XSI … most of the big house (include DD, big softimage house for many years) moved to Maya.
Hope this is helpfull, I would love to see XSI grow in a package that I can use for production but so far has not met my aspectations.
Dont forget that Maya has two types of Subds
one is for smoothing polys (somthing that XSI and others got)
its quite weak (in maya) right now but new subds system for polys is in development and it has many advantages over currently used subd schemes (dont know when it will be visible in commercial relase).
and Maya Unlimited Subds is some novel technique for directly evaluating subds (currently it uses catmull-clark but its not limited to that schemes)
BIG advantage it has over subds on poly is that it allows for many NURBS toolsl to be transfered to subds. (imagine working with nurbs but without limitations they have - thats the future (distance) of Maya Unlimited subds.
and one thing:
TRAX and SUBDS and many other things in Maya are working very good but only if you know how to use it properly.
Maya throw a lot of technology…this has always been the strong point of AW. And the package at the moment has certainly proved to be a stronghold, both in reliability and power.
Personally i prefer Softimage XSI, which i think is far more ergonomic and straight forward. Maybe stability was a big issue for version 1.0 and irix releases but 1.5 has proved to be more robust in this area and this is only the second release. This is not a product that will make it by advertisment but more a community that is growing and helping together because they really love the software…never met this anywhere. Poly tools and Subds are far more easy to use than Maya ones and yet ahead …this is only 1.5 remember.
Trax may be a good tool when used correctly but certainly not comparable to the NLA system of XSI which integrate not only animation ( shapes …). As XSI can`t be compared to maya for Dynamic and such things.
Make your choice with your feeling…think that you will have to get into the software for hours and if you don`t feel right and easy …you will have hard time learning…not creating.
When you learn fast you get fast into the creation process and companies are not necessarly looking at your software knowledge but more what you can do.